Hand tossed crust. Sauce is thin and overly seasoned. The bake was on point though. The crust had the slighest crisp but was otherwise soft. Not an overly flavorful pizza. It could be used as a benchmark for average.
bob.cook13/28/21, 9:20 p.m.
Pic is day after but we ate there. Absolutely no char on bottom kind of bland on Saturday pizza is 1/2 price
pizzalover69222/21/21, 2:55 p.m.
Average pizza. Nothing special. Football pizza dry crust and not enough sauce. Definitely better in the area.
imakepizzasoiknowmyshit12/3/20, 6:33 p.m.
I make pizza , used to work here along time ago, it’s simply dog ass! People like it but it’s only a 4.9 when it’s right out of the oven.
taylor.goulder11/17/20, 5:38 p.m.
Very thin, but supportive pizza. Would certainly consider it bar pizza. On Tuesdays they do half off pizza deals so that's something note worthy. Not the best, but definitely would order again on a Tuesday.
moshy31809/13/20, 7:22 a.m.
Ordered a pizza with as much meat as was available. Although the toppings stole the show, I did notice a rather lacking amount of tomato sauce underneath the stockpile of protein. Cheese was ok. Crust was ok. Not terribly impressed by this pie. Pappy's is a fun restaurant and they serve a nice variety of Italian eats, a shame this pizza wasn't quite as flavorful or comforting as I had hoped.
garrett.custer5/1/20, 8:37 p.m.
Could use a little more crisp on the undercarriage. The cheese was the MVP on this pie. Overall, solid pizza for this area!
drew.eddy12/22/18, 1:27 a.m.
Crust is thin with super stringy cheese. Not football pizza. Minimal hot sauce on the Buff Chicken. Solid pie.
courtney.lohr10/23/18, 10:53 p.m.
Crust is hand tossed but lacks flavor. Sauce is watery and lacks flavor. Toppings Are on point. Cheese is good.
nate.waddell19/3/18, 5:33 p.m.
If you know anything about this town its a shithole and hard to find good pizza. With that being said, for whats available in this area, 6.4