Pasquale's Restaurant and Pizzeria

Greaseball of a plain slice. Super thin, very soupy. But good flavor in the sauce and an adequate crust. The score given is for the plain slice only. The grandma slice is much better, and is definitely the way to go if you’re stopping at Pasquale’s.

Best pizza in town. Dave got a bad slice cause they were so busy he couldn’t order a whole pie I’ve never even known this place to sell pizza by the slice. It needs to be re reviewed by Dave.

THIS PIZZA WAS GOOD! I RECOMMEND TRYING IT!

Look at this floppy piece of shit. Jk, this was a good slice. It was a bit floppy but it was very flavorful. Contradictory to Dave’s scores of the nearby slice spots, I give this the edge over vinnys pizza any day

Very good grandma pie. Crispy and has great ingredients.

So I found myself in the area today and popped into Pasquale's. I had a plain pie made fresh. It's your average football pie but to my surprise the cook was really good it had a nice crisp on both undercarriage and crust. Typically these kinds of pies are very floppy and/or gummy this one wasn't it was solid. The taste is what you expect with this kind of pie. If you live in the area or find yourself passing through it's a solid choice.

Above average slice, best in Boonton. Sauce is their best feature but lacks solid crisp.

The best grandma's pizza hands down !!

Good crust was a little greasy for my liking tho. Grandmas was solid as well.

Has some flop to the slice. A lot of cheese and it’s a greasy one. Bottom of the slice is crisp. Sauce slightly sweet and tangy. Crust is nice and crisp. Overall solid pie.

Above average. Best in area 😤

Great looking pizza, good crisp, no flop, good sauce not too sweet. A little greasy. Always consistent, always delicious, Pasquale’s is the best pizza in Boonton. And when I didn’t live in Boonton, I’d drive out of my way to get it.

More grease than the poles at a Philadelphia victory celebration but I didn’t say I hate that

Absolute banger of a pizza

Grandmas Pie is an all time great in the area. Always crispy. Fresh tomatoes with a lot of taste. Will not pass by without going in.

Fantastic slice. Very crisp and no jersey flop. Sauce could use more zing but overall this pizza is electric

Delicious.

Pasquale’s Pizza is legitimately the best slice in NY / NJ. When you go make sure you try Plain, Sicilian, and Grandmas. All amazing. The Choice is Yours.