I would give it a 9.9 if you could work in the place itself. Take a step back in time for the best bar pie NJ has to offer.
noah.vanvliet2/12/21, 2:58 p.m.
The best! Garbage pie is awesome. Great undercarriage, no flop whatsoever, no grease on plate, which is extremely difficult to achieve with the garlic, mushrooms, sausage and pepperoni. Portnoy better get here soon
mh423981/23/21, 8:57 p.m.
Pie is absolutely amazing. It’s a little thicker than a traditional bar pie but still on the thinner side. No flop whatsoever and the raised crust is fantastic. Tough to compare to traditional bar pies but I think this blows places Federici’s and Nancy’s out (and they both have great pies)
frankie.s1/17/21, 10:29 p.m.
Actually really delicious pizza. The outside of this place would be deceiving, when you walk in it’s like a blast from the past. Really nice people here. The sauce, crust and quality of cheese is outstanding. A little thick, the only downside. Dave Portnoy should definitely try this place!!! I recommend it.
roda11471/15/21, 6:19 a.m.
Excellent bar pie up there with the best only better bar pies so far are Pete and Elda's (9.4), Conte's (9.2) and Fedirichi's (8.9) ...Reminds me of columbia inn (8.5) but better!!! Great tangy sauce no flop with a buttery crispy crust that reminds me of pie crust super good!!! 8.8 definitely a must try travel pie but not quite on my bucket list. That's a review!!
elliott.rehrer12/31/20, 1:12 a.m.
Pretty good pizza, they've got a cool twist on the crust by cooking it in a deep dish pan. No flop, very thicc and crispy crust, minimal char, the cheese and sauce didn't wow me tho, owner was very nice.
dguide2312/26/20, 10:56 p.m.
The best pizza ever. Family run, old school, cash only, same decorations for the last 50 years. Thin crust, crispy, perfect sauce, not greasy. Great family restaurant.
brad.christensen112/5/20, 5:26 p.m.
Amazing flavor, unique crust. One of the best pies I’ve ever had.
abbizza11/15/20, 7:13 p.m.
The pizza, the place, the vibe...cash only of course...ice filled trough pisser...frosted mugs with full and half pitchers of domestic beer...I mean who does half pitchers anymore (or ever?). Booths occupied by the same people for 50 years and rolling...with hair that hasn’t changed either. Heavy Jean Nate’ wafting in the air. Pizza - coal fired crispy crust...sauce unique flavors (Gallo jug wine?) Take it down hot and just accept that you’ll be taking the roof of your mouth down to the bone. It’s like Chernobyl just went off in your mouth. But all worth it. Pizza is that good and unlike any other you’ve had. Doesn’t comp to anything else. Wayne Gretzky great.
headshoes10/29/20, 8:52 p.m.
Very Unique... Perfect Crisp, plenty of air bubbles that’s cooked in a deep dish style pan which gives it its crust flair!
moresauce19778/27/20, 12:01 a.m.
Very unique pizza. The crust is like a crispy cracker. Cheese and sauce were middle of the road but the crust made up for it.
andres.ferradans8/20/20, 3:59 p.m.
Nice looking Pie, tastes waaaay better than it looks, def my top 5 Pizza
jxdude6/17/20, 10:35 p.m.
Only a 9.9 because a perfect 10 doesn't exist. Hands down the best there is!
tbach855/16/20, 9:43 p.m.
Good thin crust pizza with an almost cracker like taste to the dough. Dough was a little tough even as a thin crust but that made it even better. Good crust, good crunch.
kennyd3/28/20, 4:13 p.m.
Solid pizza and very nice people. Would like to go back when the restaurant is open. Interesting crust.
erich.richter3/8/20, 12:20 a.m.
It’s crispy delicious bar pizza idk how Dave hasn’t been here before. Sopranos was filmed here, Top in north jersey
samantha.joan2/15/20, 1:31 a.m.
Best pizza I’ve ever had. Crunchy, sauce was phenomenal, extra cheesy!
jbabs2/14/20, 5:20 p.m.
Terrific crust and sauce. ZERO flop. Hole in the wall bar and grill location. Very deceiving. All around great pie!
eddie.romero1/31/20, 1:48 a.m.
Prob the best pizza in North Jersey! Thin, crispy, tasty crust with no flop! This place has been open since the 1930’s and still uses the original ovens! @stoolpresidente has no idea what he’s missing! Definitely a must try. Prez needs to take a ride to P-Town!
jake.jones81/25/20, 12:45 a.m.
After my first bite I scored a 8.7 as did my girlfriend. But as I got to my second slice I thought that this pizza deserves a 9.1! Dave needs to check this place out and give it a rating!
chuck.meunier1/6/20, 12:18 a.m.
Can’t believe Dave does not have the time or stones to visit Patsys in Paterson ? Look at the reviews on this app?? Patsys lays waste to “Star Tavern “the so called best bar pie in the state. Super cool old school Tavern!
thewhitorican12/20/19, 11:43 p.m.
Definitely the best pizza in North Jersey. I'm shocked Prez still hasn't gone here.