Patsy's Tavern & Restaurant

Totally loved this place. Super old school. Fantastic people working there. The guy who made my pie was a total gem. Pizza is special stuff. Delicious super crispy crust. Perfect ratios of tasty sauce and cheese. It’s delicious out of the oven and still delicious two hours later after sitting in the box. There should be a line down the block for this pizza. Worth a significant detour to give it a shot.

Excellent NJ pizza

Much better than expected. Bar pie that was crispy and tangy.

This is the best pizza in Jersey. It’s not close.

If you like a thin, crispy bar pie with a surprising amount of tasty cheese and sauce for such a thin crust, then this is the place. Pie was cooked perfectly and well crafted. They really know how to make pizza here and have been doing it for almost a hundred years. A substantial and filling bar pie. Noticeably better than most of the famous places I’ve visited. Add in the throwback atmosphere, friendly service and cold beer,makes it a must addition to your list. Look forward to returning soon!

Worth the trip. This definitely broke into my top 10.

The longer is sat on the tray the better it got. Amazing flavor profile, great cheese-sauce-crust ratio. The crust is flakey while still remaining tasteful, not burnt at all and really stable at holding everything together. Possibly the best pizza I’ve ever had to date.

Legendary Patsy. Must have a reservation and cash only. I dig it. We got a thin crust well done pie. For the price it’s awesome. On stand alone flavor. It’s above average but not knock your balls off.

Very unique pie. Hot too.

Decent. Crust too thick. Not bad for average pie, but wouldn’t put it in the 8s. Bandit 1: 7.4 Bandit 2: 7.4

A distant, fading memory. Melting away like the snows of yesteryear. My earliest memories of pizza, all mixed together into a fairytale of my own invention. I remember eating here with my Father. He said he likes when it burns the roof of his mouth.

Unique crust that’s crispy and thin. Sauce is great with the right amount of cheese.

I do not know what’s the hype about this place Has no flavor it’s def frozen dough

Nice crunch and good sauce

I remember Portnoy said at the end of his review of this place that he should have given the pizza a 9.1 instead of an 8.2. He’s 100% right. When you get this pizza charred, it’s like eating a flat rustic freshly baked breadstick with sweet roasted sauce and perfectly melted cheese. It’s one of the greatest pizzas that I’ve ever had in the world and it’s been 10 minutes away from me this whole time. Still gotta find out though if Delucia’s is better than this place.

One of the best pizza’s in NJ. This is worth a 2 plus hour road-trip!

Exactly how the pres described it. Loved it

Alright Frankie, this pizza is second to none in my book. World class, almost pie-like crust. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio. Dynamite pizza

My God what a tasty pie- got it half-garlic , half plain, well done . Probably doesn’t travel well so have it here with a frosty cold beer . You will not be disappointed!

Thin slice, very good crisp, tangy sauce.