Paulie Gee's Short North

PARAMEDICS

Tried to take a picture while it was a whole pie and this app closed so ya know, flop is there for sure, pizza is a good crisp underneath and on the crust, cheese is very good and the multiple different cheeses is for sure a game changer, sauce is thick in some spots but overall this is above above average pizza, will get it again for sure

deliciouso

Doof

Great pizza! Nice char and just the right balance of sauce & cheese. Super thin crust

That’s a pretty solid slice of zuh. Flop is average. Not as crispy underneath as Dave would want. But still has a good fiery taste. Sauce is very good.

Pleasantly surprised, really good all around. Perfect crisp, cheese was excellent. Crust was good but not great.

The Regina- solid pie. The undercarriage needed a little more love from the oven.

This is one of the better things I’ve eaten in a long time. For square cut it’s a 9.5 the traditional slice we had thats not pictured here was an 8.5 all if it was absolutely delicious. The flavor profile on the square pie was magical. Not to mention the dough and crust are perfect. Thats a review!

Best pizza in Columbus. Crust is the most similar to Neapolitan style, but it is very light and digestible. Quality of ingredients is very high and you can taste it. I love this pizza and it remember me Italy and home!

We’ve heard this is the best za in cbus. Tried the supreme and we were disappointed. The rave reviews are a bit surprising.

Incredible crust, amazing sauce

Great pepperoni and sauce. Good pizza overall but doesn’t do anything special, just a typical thin crust wood fired pie

I think he let the waitress effect his score but who cares. Quality slice. 8.7 in the books.

the combination of hot honey and pepperoni is unmatched. this is probably the best Neapolitan pizza in Columbus. 100% would recommend.

GoreMade Pizza is better

Phil Kessel. Gore Made with the slight edge. Little crispier, little stranger, would be special.

Very similar to Gore Made. A little crispier and it would be special.

$16 for not even a one topping pizza really hurt this score. Great crust, cheese was okay, very little sauce. Not worth the price imo.

Best in Columbus? Probably

So good

Great pizza! Crisp crust! Good flavor! Just a little bit of flop! One bite, everybody knows the rules.