Paulie Gee's Slice Shop

Freddie Prince review

Horrific service. Pizza sat forever before I asked staff if it was mine. No structure.

Grandma slice. Nice flop but thin for a grandma slice. A little too much oregano

Just the Facts: Whether you’re at MSG for a sports game, or to see a great concert, make sure to get this slice on your journey.

Mary Anne spoke with me for a few asking how I was doing and what I had planned for the day, she was very pleasant and I look forward to going back

Sexy ass slice uh pizza. Curvy as hell and she bites back

Meh - the triangle and grandma were fine, but nothing to write home about. Not much sauce and a little light on the dough. The thicc one had sesame seeds on the bottom, which I’m now learning I really don’t enjoy. Paulie’s got a lot to learn.

PHILADELPHIA LOCATION. Good pizza, too thin and spread out. Excessive flop, needed more sauce. Not a bad pizza - tastes like NY/NJ slice. Good sauce, not that Philly sweet sauce bullshit. Would have again maybe.

Stock photo. Went to paulie gees in MSG. Pretty good slice for nyc. Massive portion. Basically 2 slices together. Unreal pizza for a stadium

Freddie Prinze. Legit!

Sesame seeds on the square got this place in the 7s… otherwise, not great… I’ll take upstate slices over this anytime

Good, solid NY slice.

I heard a lot of hype from this spot but maybe felt a bit let down. The pizza is fine but not the best in the immediate area.

Great flavor, good crust and crunch and flop

A bit pricy ($4 and $4.50), but solid neighborhood slices nonetheless

Big Brooklyn slices and some solid specialty pies make this a top spot in BK for pizza lovers. Not bad, didn’t blow me away, but it’s still very good pizza. They like to push this hot honey on their pies; seems like Hipster b.s. Just give me 2 large plain slices, a can of soda and I’ll be on my way.

Falls short of their main pizza joint, but this is a fantastic pie. Out of this world sauce. Crust is crazy thick (a little too thick), but still light and fluffy. Sesame seeds on the bottom are a nice touch. Completely different from the Hellboy you’d get at the regular restaurant but holds its own

Pizza Backlog 9 | 3/5/2022 | Not much to say here. Good slice. A hair above average. Also tried The Hellboy (pepperoni and hot honey) and that was a little better (7.5). Great vibe here though (9.4).

dough is perfect