Paulie Gee's Slice Shop

Freddie Prince review

Horrific service. Pizza sat forever before I asked staff if it was mine. No structure.

Just the Facts: Whether you’re at MSG for a sports game, or to see a great concert, make sure to get this slice on your journey.

Mary Anne spoke with me for a few asking how I was doing and what I had planned for the day, she was very pleasant and I look forward to going back

Sexy ass slice uh pizza. Curvy as hell and she bites back

Meh - the triangle and grandma were fine, but nothing to write home about. Not much sauce and a little light on the dough. The thicc one had sesame seeds on the bottom, which I’m now learning I really don’t enjoy. Paulie’s got a lot to learn.

Lil more flavor in the dough then typical NY slice but nothing worth the hype

PHILADELPHIA LOCATION. Good pizza, too thin and spread out. Excessive flop, needed more sauce. Not a bad pizza - tastes like NY/NJ slice. Good sauce, not that Philly sweet sauce bullshit. Would have again maybe.

Stock photo. Went to paulie gees in MSG. Pretty good slice for nyc. Massive portion. Basically 2 slices together. Unreal pizza for a stadium

Freddie Prinze. Legit!

Sesame seeds on the square got this place in the 7s… otherwise, not great… I’ll take upstate slices over this anytime

Good, solid NY slice.

I heard a lot of hype from this spot but maybe felt a bit let down. The pizza is fine but not the best in the immediate area.

Great flavor, good crust and crunch and flop

A bit pricy ($4 and $4.50), but solid neighborhood slices nonetheless

Big Brooklyn slices and some solid specialty pies make this a top spot in BK for pizza lovers. Not bad, didn’t blow me away, but it’s still very good pizza. They like to push this hot honey on their pies; seems like Hipster b.s. Just give me 2 large plain slices, a can of soda and I’ll be on my way.

Falls short of their main pizza joint, but this is a fantastic pie. Out of this world sauce. Crust is crazy thick (a little too thick), but still light and fluffy. Sesame seeds on the bottom are a nice touch. Completely different from the Hellboy you’d get at the regular restaurant but holds its own

Pizza Backlog 9 | 3/5/2022 | Not much to say here. Good slice. A hair above average. Also tried The Hellboy (pepperoni and hot honey) and that was a little better (7.5). Great vibe here though (9.4).

dough is perfect