Paulie's Pizza of Schenectady

Strong parm taste, which is great!

Sauce on the sweeter side, has flop, average to above average crust. Average cheese, high quality football pizza

Sauce is watery. The sauce tastes like Hunts, straight from the can. Basically a tasteless pizza. I’ve had better frozen pizzas.

Spectacular slice. I want to preface this by saying this is a reheat slice, which I personally think is the best way. Every bite was crispy, under-carriage perfect, sauce perfect, it might be the best slice I've had in the area, including DeFazios.

Simply delicious

Perfect crisp, great flavor… maybe a little more salt in the dough but it’s dank fo show

Why have not more people discovered this? I accidentally ate 6 slices in ten minutes… worth the pain

Perfecto

Super tasty pie with more sturdy undercarriage a solid 8. One of the best around no doubt.

A good quality pizza. No flop, good flavor. Nice cheese sauce combination. I will gladly eat their pizza again.

It’s very, very decent. Some really good bites but the dough is bland as hell. Onto Cincinnati.

Solid football pizza. Crust is light with an excellent crunch, flavors are on point. Definitely a go-to slice while in the Schenectady area.

Decent. Extremely average Margherita pizza. Fresh mozzarella was good, sauce nothing special, the basil was slightly less than fresh. Could have used a touch more oil and more crisp in the crust. 6.4 that is a review my dudes

Not bad. It could have been served hotter. 30 seconds in the oven wasn't enough. The sauce was simple, which is good. The crust was crispy and the cheese was good enough for a 7.

Good cheese and sauce combo.

Good solid traditional pie. If their box says “Hot, Fresh and Delicious” it’s all true. Pizza can almost always be crispier for me, this slice Included. Good slice though. 7.3 that’s my review

Attentive and friendly staff... however, this dough/crust has zero flavor and the sauce and cheese are forgettable