Paulie's Pizzeria

Triple Fucking Mint!! Couldn’t wait to get here.. everyone telling me better than Joe N Pats.. and it was!! Giving it my highest score ever!! 9.4!! Job well done Paulie!! Duchess wanted another slice!!

Light crust, medium-thin. Semi-Sweet sauce, proper cheese ratio - voted best Pizza on Staten Island.

Great sauce great cheese great crust minimal flop solid slice

For a plain scilian. It was ok. Sauce was watery. Cheese was good. Bottom was a little burnt. Dough was pretty good

One of my favorite slices on Staten Island. It's a nice thin slice with good flavor.

Amazing pizza, great value for a pie. Thin crunchy crust and perfect combo of cheese and sauce. Highly recommend

Fantastic thin crust

A bit Saucy , which some people may not enjoy . But it’s a very good sauce . Solid solid slice . Go for the Margherita Pie ...

Excellent pie. Sauce and cheese are from top notch ingredients and you can taste the quality. Dough is cooked perfectly. Their regular slice is thin crust and probably one of the best on Staten Island, a borough filled with top notch pizza joints. Don’t be afraid to add a topping or two as well. I highly recovered pepperoni which is cooked to perfection. Bonus Chicken Parmigiana Review- An all time classic from the restaurant. Great sauce and cheese with incredible flavor.

Excellent slice. Thin and crunch. Sweet sauce