Good sauce and cheese but the crust was way too chewy. Not crispy. Drunk slice IMO
ryan.rutherford9/13/21, 10:08 p.m.
Thick, mightily heavy, super doughy & extra cheesy, this is filling “Football Pizza” at its finest 🏈. As you can see in the pic, the dough and crust are practically spilling out of the box. While the dough is plentiful, it’s of pretty average taste, somewhat firm undercarriage leading to a gigantically puffy thick crust; it’s like eating a loaf of bread with each slice. The sauce is solid, yet unspectacular, definitely better than basic. The cheese is in line with the thick theme of the pie, heavy & tasty, nothing special, a little oily but very well balanced with the sauce. While none of the ingredients will blow you away, this is a very good, family friendly, neighborhood pizza, perfect for Friday Family Pizza Nights and Football Sundays.
stevenstrangles3/22/20, 8:31 p.m.
Wow. Blown away by the “Crushed Slice” from Pelham Pizza. Listen, I’ll put Pelham Pizza up against any other Pizza in Westchester. It’s simply that good. Watch the video for the full breakdown!
62 views•3 likes
cschmitz10/29/19, 4:36 p.m.
Perfect slice. Could eat this every day of my life. Sauce, crust, cheese, everything is perfect with this slice. Definitely going to have it again.
raymond.rojas10/3/19, 10:16 p.m.
Definitely a place you want to do fresh pie. Good taste crust could be better on the first few bites. The back crust is pretty good. Wish the bottom of my reheated pizza didn’t had charcoal or burnt stuff on it. I’ve had their fresh pies and I’d score that a 8.6 or even a 9 if it’s clean. Pretty good overall.
bob.moppie7/19/19, 7:09 p.m.
Heavy Thick cheese. Doughy doughy. Undercooked. When you see cornmeal on the bottom they are keeping ovens too low and trying to add crisp. This place does that. Full flop in effect. So salty you’ll be thirsty for days.
chris.pettus7/10/19, 6:34 p.m.
Very good slice. This was definitely my type of pizza, rich flavor, good crust and sauce
quinlan.crowley7/6/19, 7:45 p.m.
Good slice. Quality crisp, thin but not too thin. Excellent sauce, love the people who work here
justin.matteo6/24/19, 8:41 p.m.
Featured in the photo is the “Crush”. Crushed red pepper mixed into the sauce, a little ricotta cheese and of course all atop the famous Pelham pizza dough. No Flop! I grew up on Pelham Pizza. This is my hometown pizza place. So yeah I’m biased! Pelham Pizza is more than just great pizza. It’s been owned and operated by a great family since day one. The staff has always been kind and treats all their guests like family. More than just pizza, Pelham Pizza offers a variety of traditional Italian dishes. Each cooked to perfection by the highest caliber professionals in the business. From soups to salads and everything in between, all their entrees provide exquisite, home cooked taste. Buon appetito!
hughjanus164/24/19, 10:35 p.m.
Pizza was a little burned, crust was a workout, but the sauce and cheese were good.
thinnewyorkcrisp3/23/19, 2:59 a.m.
Great slice. Sauce is tangy, right amount of cheese, right balance between flop and crisp.
seanbrady1/27/19, 4:53 p.m.
Picked up and ate later. Air Fryer re-heat. Very good pizza. Meatball was great. Probably a 8+.
brycejsp1/9/19, 11:07 p.m.
Good amount of grease and flop. Good cheese and sauce however. 7.7.