Was lukewarm when it arrived. Pizza man did not bring it in a warming sleeve. Very disappointed after Dave’s review. Very chewy. Sauce is good. But crust was one of the worst I’ve had.
cassiepagnozzi3/24/21, 6:02 p.m.
Valid thin slice pizza, pres gave it a fair rating. Also got a plain Sicilian, could have been better. Not shown in the picture but we got their buffalo chicken Sicilian- by far the best I’ve ever had. Pres did not disappoint🙌 SUPER nice guys in here too, gotta contribute that to the score as well.
anthony.apreda13/24/21, 3:14 a.m.
Was not impressed. It’s okay football style pizza but nothing to rave home about
lennoll13/12/21, 9:03 p.m.
It’s decent. Good crispy crust, especially given its thickness. But sauce taste was a bit lacking, and cheese was kind of a greasy mess. A long way down from Dave's 8.5 and even further from "Perfect”
craig.o'sullivan3/11/21, 2:23 a.m.
Even though I’ve live 15 minutes away, I had never heard of this pizzeria until I saw Dave’s review. Dave visited in late December and was highly impressed. The place looks like a dive more so than the typical pizzeria in North Jersey, but the quality of the pizza is definitely above average for the area. I got a personal pie for $10 with anchovies and peppers, and the anchovies were as good as it gets. The sauce and crust weren’t anything special though. After Dave’s strong review I was a bit disappointed. Not worth the trip to a neighborhood that is lacking. I give it a 7.5 as you can’t beat the value.
diablo2/24/21, 5:02 p.m.
Very good pizza!! Crust was very crunchy, which is something you dont find in this area very often. I am going to guess that they make their own sauce. Was not overly sweet like most pizzerias that used canned sauce. If they upped their cheese game, I would raise score to a 8.7. It was a little greasy, which I have to contribute to a lesser quality cheese.
tommyg6881/26/21, 8:26 p.m.
Went there had two slices were very good. Decided to go back and get a whole fresh pie to give an honest review. The slices were thinner more what I like the pie being fresh tasted better but was thicker then what I had the first time and less crispy. Overall a good pie I would definitely Ask for it thin and crispy next time
etuero1/6/21, 6:28 p.m.
Good slice if pizza , good thin cooked well. Taste is more on the plain side or maybe i have covid 🤷🏿♂️ niceee crisppp
leo.hernandez12/31/20, 5:02 p.m.
Worked in the neighborhood for about 4 years.always passed it but never stopped in. The name turned me off. I stand corrected. The crust is cooked great. It's a little overcooked so you can taste the flavor. The sauce is smooth and not too much... just perfect. It leaves you with a good memorable after taste. Must admit...it's really really good.
eakgeak12/29/20, 4:44 a.m.
Yeah I know, horrible lighting on pizza. Don’t judge a pizza by the photo- Crust: 9.5 Sauce: 8.1 Cheese: 8.3 Flop: 8.5 Final Score: 8.6 P̶e̶r̶f̶e̶c̶t̶ Phenomenal pizza
elyseparker12/28/20, 5:42 p.m.
Very good, thick dough, no flop. Cheese is tasty. Sauce is solid but can use a bit more zest but very good!
chadt12/28/20, 5:40 p.m.
Good crust, good structure (no flop) good cheese flavor, sauce could use a touch more flavor still a food pie
anthony.scerbo12/27/20, 6:33 p.m.
Hey David, i am 10 yrs old and consider myself a pizza expert.. Sorry to say you were quite a bit off on this rating. Good pizza, no grease (which is how I like it) but not enough cheese and when the slices were pulled apart it was very messy. Can I recommend you to try Brunos in Lyndhurst? I'll even meet you there.