Tasty but sloppy. Like my 20’s it was impossible to manage. A bit tighter and this square delight would’ve made it into the 7’s
chris.jf077/3/21, 5:07 p.m.
Excellent pizza! The sauce is to die for and is the main reason for my high score. Also, the crust was very good as well. One of the better square pizzas I’ve had!
lennoll16/5/21, 12:57 p.m.
Another star player at the Columbus Farmers Market. Similar style to Kate & Al’s, but with a lighter, fluffier crust.
bps_hockey504/18/21, 6:55 p.m.
Great pizza. Similar to the pizza from home Santucci’s. Worth the wait in the mart madness.
billiott4/3/21, 8:09 p.m.
Crust is light, tasty, and supports the “mess” heaved upon it. Sauce is sweet and delicious. The pepperoni is the freshest and best I’ve ever had on a pizza. Tremendous pie overall.
bgraham3/14/21, 9:16 p.m.
Amazing texture a d flavors. Melts in your mouth. Light and fluffy crust but strong enough to hold onto the ton of fresh tomatoes on top. Cheese under the sauce is mild and creamy. This is a pizza we plan a day around. It’s served in the most bizarre market in NJ but it’s amazing.
repsreviews3/5/21, 8:43 p.m.
Not generally my style but it was good. Sweeter sauce and good cheese but the dough was the highlight for sure. Super light and super fluffy.
meron.rubinowitsch11/6/20, 6:16 p.m.
Dough could be a little more cooked for me. Wife liked it more than me. Really liked the sweet sauce.
daveturner10/9/20, 8:43 p.m.
Got a half Sicilian pie, but the pizza really reminds me of the traditional philadelphia tomato pies. Sauce had a lot of good flavor. Cheese under sauce.
justin.turner10/9/20, 8:43 p.m.
Almost similar to a tomato pie on a visual standpoint. A lot of sauce, which is on the sweeter end, and little cheese. Quite tasty!
joseph.volponi3/14/20, 2:20 p.m.
Pete’s is by far one of the best kept secrets in NJ. Who looks for pizza this good in a flea market? Excellent pizza and the most important thing to me is the consistency of their pizza. I have never had a bad pizza at Pete’s. Awesome pizza. Dave has to add this place to his next Jersey road trip !
slice_harper3/10/20, 3:54 p.m.
Second review but this time it was actually on site. This pizza slaps harder than an angry pimp. We drive almost a half hour from Philly just to get it & it’s worth it. Great, fresh ingredients.
david.nevil12/29/19, 5:47 p.m.
Favorite Sicilian slice out there. Sauce is pretty sweet, pizza is really good. 8.2.
headshoes12/8/19, 9:08 p.m.
Yes it’s a tomato pie ... Yes it’s saucy, Yes you will need napkins the sauce is a tad sweeter then their neighbors down the hall (Kate & Al’s)
michael.cocosis11/28/19, 3:26 p.m.
Ridiculous. This pizza has a slight crisp, while in between thin crust & pan pizza. EXTRA saucy...which it should be because this pizza is all about the sauce, it's amazing. Sauce on top of cheese. It comes it kinda sloppy because of it, but zero flop. Near perfect.
gary.rondeau10/3/19, 4:31 p.m.
Really great pizza. Sauce is excellent. Very messy and huge flop brings the score down a little.
subdiver9/14/19, 4:40 p.m.
Had to walk to the other side of the Columbus Farmers Market. Not really worth the walk even. This pizza is about average, it’s OK. Good sauce but pizza is too doughy with not enough crunch in the crust and why do they put Parmesan cheese in there too? Average at best.
raulfpizzacrew6/16/19, 4:29 p.m.
Nice crust, sweet sauce, not your typical plain pizza but good. Service is very good.
john.bunce14/21/19, 6:36 p.m.
Dough is amazing... crunch but soft at the same time. Tangy sauce and perfect amount of cheese.