Peyton's Pie Company

Very good Margharita pie!!! Could have been in the oven for another few seconds though..

It’s really good especially if you are in Flowery Branch. That’s your option. Toss out all the ridiculous 10’s and the 9.9 scores, and some of the lower scores. That gets you where the real rating is. Very good pizza. Floppy cause we had some toppings but good. Regular cheese is good too.

🇮🇹 good pie. I like the fresh basil v. Charing the basil with the pizza. Tried a specialty pizza first time and was not that crazy about it. Went second time for a margarita.

Pizza was really good. I would say best place in flowery branch and a really cool place. Customer service was really good as well

too much cheese, needs more sauce and more flavorful sauce. crust was very good and connor here smacked it down.

Well cooked pizza! Really great sweet tangy sauce, great crust, great crisp! Great undercarriage best pizza in Gainesville/ flowery branch area!

The crust is delicious- perfectly charred with a great undercarriage. Sauce is unique with a bit of a bite. Toppings are great, especially the pepperoni. Bbq chicken pizza has also a favorite because of the one of a kind bbq sauce. Nick and Allison do it right and really deserve a 10 but Dave would never allow a 10. BONUS: get the Alabama wings. That sauce will change your life!

The pizza is good, the crust is great. The pepperoni that supposed to be the “greasy New Yorker” didn’t have a lot of cheese and the sauce was spicy which pulled attention away from the taste of the other toppings. Good for local but no where near New York pizza. That’s a review

Great pizza, good under carriage!

Got the last pizza of the night. They sell out it’s so good. 9.2 for the best pie in 100 miles.

Best Pie I’ve ever had!!

Fresh Pie! Greasy New Yorker here - absolutely fantastic. Dave would be impressed.

We got the Margherita, the Meatball Sammie and the Pepperoni and everyone was amazing! So good. I’m a pizza snob so this 10 score is not just a gift. Awesome good. Great service. Highly recommend

Had the Pork Belly + Pineapple pizza and the Wild Farm Greens salad. They were both fantastic! And funky but very delicious pizza with fresh ingredients. Crust is very thin and crunchy. Small cozy little spot - highly recommend!

Really excellent pizza. A close second to Antico pizza.