Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Cheese overload! Add an extra 1/2 point if that’s your preference. The amount of cheese killed the sauce to ratio and made it an oil slick. But the crust wasn’t heavy and handled the weight the cheese. The flavor profile wasn’t enough to elevate it, but was good enough as the ingredients were solid.

If you can even find the regular slice in here, that’s what I scored… stopped by “for a slice” with my girl because she used to frequent this place in her youth… left with every pie under the sun. It was ok… heavy on the cheese.. I like it more crunchy as well… it was fine..

Grandma

Drunk Sicilian

Major flop, hard to enjoy it, but it’s not bad

Great cheese, sauce, little flop

BBQ and Grandpa pie. Good football pizza. Lots of cheese and sauce.

Hard to rate Phil’s on a regular slice because I always felt they were more known for their specialty slices. Great service. Nice people. Regular slice was just a bit average. Cheese was heavy at the top. Also kind of small for a single slice? Usually if you order single slices they come slightly bigger. This was just a reheated slice from a regular pie. Not bad, though. Still love Phil’s and definitely love their specialty selection.

Classic New York flop A+ crust Greasy and messy cheese Great for Friday night dinner

Plenty of New York flop but very greasy and not a ton of flavor. Pepperoni is needed to makeup for the lack of taste.