Download
Home
Top Restaurants
Pi Pizzeria

Pi Pizzeria

11 West Creek Road, Nantucket, Massachusetts
Pizza Review
1 like
phinneyd on One Bite Pizza App

phinneyd

11/8/20 3:53 PM

The Marg Pizza at Pi is Money! The Rustica is the best Specialty Pie. A must have!
Pizza Review
patrick.furlow16/5/25, 6:09 p.m.
Pizza review

7.9

We got two pizzas and this was the average score between the two. We got pepperoni with extra cheese. We scored it a 7.7 and then the other pizza was The Great Italian. We scored that an 8.1. Good pizza. We would order it crispy next time we come. Recommend. The owner was very nice as well.
0 likes
Pizza Review
keggs4/14/25, 2:44 p.m.
Pizza review

8.3

Review #53 Low key hidden gem on the island.. excellent wood fired style pizza.. the other meals are great too.. DRILL IT JACK
0 likes
Pizza Review
laurence.scaglioni3/9/25, 2:29 p.m.
Pizza review

5.1

Pi pizzeria angier street, not worth it!
0 likes
Pizza Review
matthewjay7/10/24, 10:35 p.m.
Pizza review

7.9

Slight flop but sauce and cheese were good
0 likes
Pizza Review
thub876/2/24, 2:46 p.m.
Pizza review

8.7

Easily the best pizza on island. Great charred, flavorful crust and high quality ingredients. Floppier than a typical Apizza but makes up for it in flavor.
0 likes
Pizza Review
zeusaftermath7/1/22, 12:41 a.m.
Pizza review

8.5

Best pizza on Nantucket! I know we are from CT and live right outside New Haven. Bravo!
0 likes
Pizza Review
tom.ruggia8/7/21, 6:43 p.m.
Pizza review

8.8

Legit! We were on Nantucket for a short trip and the boss made us a pie even though they had just closed. Super nice crew and fantastic pizza.
1 like
Pizza Review
wesley.jansdn6/9/21, 11:09 p.m.
Pizza review

8.5

Marg was amazing. If you’re going speciality, go with the Rustica. It is an amazing pizza
0 likes
Pizza Review
chris.shackleton12/9/20, 9:50 p.m.
Pizza review

10

The Rustica pizza is without question the best pizza I have ever eaten.
0 likes
Pizza Review
savystewart9/14/20, 10:46 p.m.
Pizza review

9.7

Just amazing. Great flavor. Perfect crust.
1 like
Pizza Review
brian.rawson9/7/20, 11:11 p.m.
Pizza review

8.5

33 views•1 like
Pizza Review
pierre.planche12/8/19, 2:24 a.m.
Pizza review

7.2

1 like
Pizza Review
nick.mitchell410/26/19, 10:39 p.m.
Pizza review

8.2

Wood fired giving it great crisp. Really burned my face off on this one. Sauce has a fair amount of tang. The pie has a nice body to it - not super greasy or sloppy in the middle. Had the chocolate hazelnut gelato for dessert. A true taste of etaly.
3 likes
Pizza Review
clo9/16/19, 12:21 a.m.
Pizza review

8.4

Quality slice
0 likes
Pizza Review
greg_oc9/3/19, 3:36 p.m.
Pizza review

8.4

When they brought this bad boy out I knew this was going to be a solid score. All the characteristics of a solid pizza. Nice char, good ingredients, thin, and crispy. The best pizza I’ve had in my short stay on Nantucket
2 likes
Pizza Review
griffin.deane8/15/19, 12:26 a.m.
Pizza review

7.6

0 likes
Pizza Review
jack.murdock8/12/19, 11:51 p.m.
Pizza review

7.5

3 likes
Pizza Review
griffin.grise8/12/19, 11:50 p.m.
Pizza review

7.9

Uncle said it was good so I thought I would give it a shot. Pleasantly surprised although it was better in the past.
0 likes
Pizza Review
mellowblack7/12/19, 4:06 p.m.
Pizza review

8.5

Great Pie! Tangy sauce and a crisp crust.
0 likes
Pizza Review
njguywithbkties5/11/19, 5:27 p.m.
Pizza review

8.5

Very good pizza. Would like to see them have a regular cheese pizza on the menu in addition to the Margherita but otherwise no complaints. Surprised at how good the crust was, tasted similar to NYC pizza.
1 like
Pizza Review
jeremy.bean5/5/19, 10:27 p.m.
Pizza review

9.2

Fuck cinco de Mayo, this pizza eats tacos raw. Best pizza sauce in the game. Nantucket golden cookie days forever!
84 views•0 likes
Pizza Review
lukeduke99998/28/18, 7:59 p.m.
Pizza review

8.4

1 like
Pizza Review
stoolpresidente7/18/16, 6:00 p.m.
Pizza review

8.6

6,069 views•133 likes