I got a decent slice here. The dough was the best part. It actually had a reverse flop, thing curled up like a banana, but nice and crispy through out. I did not love the sauce and the cheese was unremarkable. Have to go with a 7.4 score. It is what it is.
shawn.piatek9/3/21, 1:17 a.m.
Crust is super light, nice crisp. Sauce with a bit of zing and good cheese with almost no grease. Really good pie. Bonus canoli review: Whole world of yum! Sweet and creamy filling, crispy and tasty shell 8.7
imjohn.papajohn4/13/21, 8:36 p.m.
Got a single slice, not a pie - No flop, good crunch, repeat crunches throughout the chew was a plus. Sauce and cheese didn't taste great, kind of bland, but it was a decent town slice. Rookie score, but it was just a 7...it wasn't a 7.1 and it was better than any 6 considering I didn't get it fresh in a pie
anthonyg8/14/20, 10:08 p.m.
Fresh crust, cheesy and good sauce. Toss up between this and Rosemarie’s for best pizza in Farmingdale
snyder20247/1/20, 6:09 p.m.
It's almost like we ordered from a different place than my last review. Much better.
21 views•1 like
sgt.pizza3/30/20, 6:42 p.m.
Regular: fair amount of grease, good crisp to the dough. Sauce tastes excellent and cheese is a good quality. 8.1 Sicilan: good char on the bottom, nice and crispy, good tasting sauce and cheese. 8.4
mario.bruno8/17/19, 6:23 p.m.
The reason for the plate pic is to show how little grease is on the TWO slices I had! Cheese to sauce ratio is perfect slice was crisp with zero flop! Staff is super nice! I’ll be back for sure, review is a 9.3
asf57166/4/19, 7:20 p.m.
Pizza had some classic NY flop. It was cooked well but still suffered from some doughiness though the crust was very good. The blend was okay but nothing special. Overall a decent but forgettable slice
dominic.marciano3/24/19, 5:43 p.m.
Thin and crispy, no flop. A little oily and wish sauce had a little more tang.
vincent.carucci10/26/18, 10:28 p.m.
Unbelievable slice. One of the better slices I've ever had. Nice sauce, perfect crust, great service.