Piccolo Ristorante Bellmore

This place has the absolute best pizza. I spent an entire year going to every single place on Long Island looking for a pie that has the right flavor. That is done the right way They all suck. There are some that are OK but no one can beat the extra cheese pie from here. What you are looking at is a masterpiece. This is the color you are looking for. The cheese and the sauce blend together to make an amazing flavor. They don’t use cheap cheese. The sauce actually has flavor and seasoning. Most places just throw crushed tomato on the bottom. You can tell just by looking at this pie that it’s gonna taste delicious. I order from here at least five times a week. No one can go toe to toe with them in this area. It’s not even close. Don’t believe me order an extra cheese pie and tell me if it’s not the best pizza you’ve ever had in Long Island. I spent countless hours and endless amounts of dollars trying different places. This is my home now. It’s very rare to find a place that does everything the right way.

Decent not great. Crispy crust, but flavor was kind of bland. Fresh ingredients though

Buffalo chicken slice

Really interesting flavor. Almost tasted like it was dusted with grated cheese. It really made it hard to focus on anything other flavor profile. A little disappointing because it was cooked perfectly, was thin and had crisp.

Sauce was phenomenal and the cheese was great. Dough could use some work tho. And it wouldn’t hurt to ask for extra sauce but overall a nice pie

Very meh