Pie in the Sky Pizza

Pretty good for the price!

Not much to say about it, great location by Valhalla and Courtyard hooligans for some beers and a soccer game. As far as the pizza, it’s good, just nothing really sticks out. Sauce is passive and the dough is soft- probably pre-made. They get .2 for the atmosphere and catcalling that got my attention and my fatass in the door. Not bad though.

Light crisp crust good, light sauce bad. Football pizza with potential.

Huge flop, super thin crust but no crunch. Good crunch on big crust though. Very greasy, also noticed the oven was smoking when I walked in, they took my slice out of there and it tasted like smoke, but like burnt food smoke. Good drunk pie, good deal - I ate the plain slice before the photo, people were very nice, cool location although the outside of the cafe is kind of gross - not on them though. 6.4. That’s a review.

Best slice in Uptown

I'm only open for lunch kind of flop. Cheese was great, crust is super crispy. I wish I could have this pizza more often.

Decent slice. Had some rookie scores but the flop was to much.

With ranch 7.3 perfect flop a little greasy but dab it up and enjoy the score

Strong slice.

Probably the best pizza in uptown... that’s not saying a lot. Average slice!

Extremely solid, best NY style pizza in uptown

Had the pesto chicken and three meat pie. Is a pretty decent deal at 2 and a drink for $6.50. But 100% an average slice of pizza.

Get the Sicilian.

Only open for lunch. Not terrible, but nothing to write home about