harperpizza8/8/20, 2:15 a.m.
Got this delivered so it was not as hot as we’d normally like - but still delicious, just the right amount of crispy, delicious cheese and sauce, a little greasy. One red sauce and one red sauce with pepperoni. Big pies! Uneven slices but I think that’s part of the schtick.
lenny.bourgeois6/20/20, 12:11 a.m.
I got this delivered so this want be a particularly accurate review. Sauce was delicious and the dough was full of flavor. Wish the crust was a little crispier
ggrec5/10/20, 12:44 a.m.
Best NY slice I’ve had in Chi so far. During pandemic so had to wait outside where It ended up being cold by the time I got it. Nice crisp, sauce and dough were great. Not a fan of smaller slice would have like to see them a little bigger. Will definitely be back to try after pandemic to give a better score - That’s a review
pizzabri2/23/20, 4:06 a.m.
Tomato Pie. Really nice crisp and texture to the crust. Score would be higher if it weren’t for the heavy hand on the garlic.
girthbrooks2/22/20, 3:37 a.m.
Wow! Not very often a place lives up to its hype. Great bar atmosphere and does pizza right. I ordered the “red” style first and it was phenomenal, they came out and even asked me if it was well done enough. Every ingredient was cooked to perfection and crust had a perfect burnt crunch. “White” Pizza was pretty good as well, not for me but people seemed to really like it. Very happy!
pizzamd2/3/20, 4:42 p.m.
Thin crust with some good crisp. Closest thing to a NY slice that I’ve had in Chi. Not a fan of the small slices they cut it into. Pizza is a little floppy, but sauce and cheese make up for it. Overall good quality pizza. I will definitely be back. Ask for it well done 👌🏻
david.dillingham11/25/20, 6:45 p.m.
Pizza is very good but best if it’s just cheese or pepperoni. Keep it classic. Shocking Dave hasn’t made a attempt to go here but I guess I can understand when he’s to busy covering stories about the Kardashians.
josh551341/25/20, 2:40 p.m.
Large flop and incredibly greasy. It must have been undercooked. I could assume we just got a bad pie. Good sauce, however
matt.tetkoskie1/4/20, 8:46 p.m.
One of the better pizzas in the city. Solid crisp, thin crust, a little grease. Worth going out of your way for
alex.dewitt12/18/19, 2:02 a.m.
Great ambience and friendly staff. Home brewed beer is out of this world. Pizza is delicious and very fresh ingredients. Sauce has got great tang. Could have just been cooked a few minutes longer. Great pizza experience.
jose.toribio11/27/19, 1:41 a.m.
Good looking, but greasy. The crisp and crust were great. Tiny flop, but nothing that bad. Strong pizza. I think Frankie would agree.
tony-pajamas10/26/19, 1:30 a.m.
Decent at best. This is CHICAGO... We pride ourselves on STELLAR pizza. This flop is next level and the toppings make it far from a real slice. Atmosphere is great and employees are A1. Still, if you’re looking for the beat slice in town, this is like a fart to the mouth. Come for a good time, stay for the people, let the pizza slide from your mind like their toppings do from their dough. Follow me on Insta for the truth @tony_sipz
julian.akiva10/20/19, 12:16 a.m.
Pretty good. Crispy. A little hard and cheese kinda falls off.