Pier 76

Pretty good the sauce was a little bit sweet crust was amazing and thin also cheese was beautiful pretty slow service but overall it was amazing and comes second in my book

This is awesome pizza, by 2nd favorite in the NYC area. Definitely worth the ferry ride out to SI. Lavish style crust is superb, beyond words. Cheese is fantastic, sauce is slightly, slightly too sweet but I am nitpicking here. It’s something you must try. This pizza fucks.

As good as Joe and Pats ! Got a great pie, lots of sauce and cheese for a thin bar pie

Great flavored tangy sauce, a nice thickness, a little cheese heavy, but the crust had a good crunch.

All that was left on New Year’s Eve so it felt like it’d around a while but still a better than average square. Reheated good very crispy and crunchy with good cheese pull but the sauce was lacking the it factor. Maybe coulda just used a little more or I need to try it fresh either way still a great place and I’ll be back for the round pie.

Extremely thin & crispy. Great sauce flavor and perfect cheese

Crispy crust, no flop, no grease, lots of sauce and cheese... what’s not to like? One bite everyone knows the rules

Great pie (can’t beat the weekday price!) Cheese Sauce ratio went perfect with the crunch. *Vodka square hella delicious too

Really oily. Major flop

I was excited to try Pier 76 because of their connection to Joe and Pats, but overall it was underwhelming. Not bad but with so many good pizzeria’s close by I probably wouldn’t order any time soon.

Loved this pie. Nice and thin, good sauce to cheese ratio and great crisp as well. A little greasy and waited forever and a day

For a plain scilian. Cheese and crust was top notch. Sauce ok. Great slice

Great crust & flop!

Very good slice. I’ve reviewed their Royal Pier earlier which is a different/good but heavy. Gave it a 7.1 This is their plain cheese and is excellent. Cheese and sauce were a great combo. What pushed it over was the crust, and I usually don’t factor crust in too heavy. This is a light, thin crust and it was very good. Overall, great slice.

They make a very good pie and always hook us up at the ferry.

Owned by the owners of Joe and Pats, it’s pretty much the same pie/slice. Cracker style crust, cubes of mozzarella, and nice tangy sauce. My only issue with this place is customer service. It’s a little suspect sometimes, so it drops the score a bit. If you can’t get to Joe and Pats, Pier 76 is as good.

Great pizza! Has good crunch and they use good quality cheese. Would definitely come back