Pinocchio's Pizza & Subs

Ordered Sicilian sausage, crust fell off when I took a bite, had to eat knife and fork. Boola boola

The cheese here was quality as well as the sauce. The Sicilian slice > round slice. The sicilian slice was very good. Good crunch, and tasted fresh. I would not get the round pizza here and I would stick solely with the sicilian

Never understood the fame among the college students

Classic slice, great Sicilian football pie. Gotta love it

Tasty

Best pizza in Harvard Square and possibly the best Sicilian in Boston. Soft, chewy, and crunchy - delicious.

Got it cold but it’s still solid

Spinach pizza is elite - will come back often

One bite, everyone knows the rules. If you want a Sicilian slice the only way to do better than Pinocchio’s is to get into a Time Machine to 1979 and have my mom make it.

if this was my local spot I’d have no complaints but nothing special. Sauce is pretty good. Cheese extremely mid, crust bland. Would never travel for this

This is more akin to a NY grandma slice than Sicilian. It's thin light and crisp edges. Perfect cheese/ sauce ratio

Now this is authentic pizza ! Only completion is in New Haven CT. They also serve Sicilian style . The only one who made it better was my Sicilian Grandmother. Score 9.9 on the Sicilian Style

Sicilian was a 7. Regular was a 5

Solid Sicilian; I crave this slice from time to time. Love that its tucked away in a side alley. Tons of pizza joints have pics of celebs on the wall, but you really get a sense that Damon, the Zuck and other famous Harvard grads legit loved (and still love) this slice

Fluffy, yet crisp crust. Cheese is good. Lacking in sauce