Pinocchios Pizza & Subs

First time trying Sicilian Style. I liked it, not a lot though. A little greasy, too heavy, and needed more tang. Fantastic crisp though.

A Greek esque Sicilian slice. Crispy crust with a thick, heavy, body. Red sauce is flavorful. Layer of cheese is perfect pull-away consistency

such a classic spot. Any Bostonian who doesn’t know Pinocchio’s is from Wellesley.

Fuck I’m gonna miss this place

This is football pizza! Solid pizza. Wish the sauce had a little more kick to it. Cheese is good. Crust was ehh. Good pizza but could use a kick to be great.

Light, airy, good flavor in the sauce. Nice crunch as well. I've ordered a pizza from here before which I think is better than this slice. That was more in the high 7s or even low 8s.

Solid for a thick pizza. Crust breaks too easily.

Greasy and cheese falls off, super crispy on the bottom and soft.. no flop...but it tastes like a piece of pizza that is separated by its cheese and bread... 6.9 I guess... I expected better from Boston pizza, hope I’m not too picky

large regular cheese. kinda fire

Decent amount of flop, terrific crust, cheese is not bad. Lots of grease keeps it from 8 but really good pizza overall

Not a bad slice. That's a review

Legendary Sicilian slice pizza for yuppie Harvard students. I can’t lie, shit is delish!

Easy 9.1 - FANTASTIC PIZZA!

Very impressed with this place the hype is real regular slice definitely 7.5 good sauce Good tang good crust Sicilian pepperoni 7.3 Good sauce good crust nice basil taste would definitely go back 🙌🏾

After Regina’s, this is, in my opinion, the best slice you can get in the Greater Boston area. Lovely pan-induced crunch on the bottom, and airy soft dough on top holds an outstanding cheese/sauce combo. Never disappoints.

You will dream of Pinocchio's many years after you have it. It's a return for life pizza.

Garlic slice 9.3 with ease