Pizza Joe

Not a bad Sicilian but not a great Sicilian. Sauce was ok. The crust was very good. Have ordered reg slices in the past. They were good and I would return. But not for Sicilian. Great service and reasonable prices

The Sicilian pizza was one of the best I ever had. Full of flavor and cooked to perfection. Tried my wives regular pepperoni slices and that would be a 7.2 at best. Nothing spectacular with the regular slices but the Sicilian is a home run.

Lots of reviews of this place say their Sicilian is the best in town but unfortunately they didn’t have one ready at the moment to compare next to the regular cheese. This thing is loaded with cheese, it flops midway up the slice but not because of grease it’s simply all the cheese. The slice is also super thick which I don’t mind the problem is it wasn’t cooked long enough so it was really chewy when combined with the dump truck of cheese they poured on it. Everything taste wise with this pizza is good, it’s just a badly put together slice, a layer less of cheese and a few minutes longer in the oven and this be a 6.5 slice. I’ll give this place another try in the future(although they did skimp on the toppings)

I had a double slice before the storm of hurricane Ida sets in here. To be fair, I enjoyed the slices, they were tasty but needed to be cooked to a little more crisp for me. I should have got the square slice, everyone seems to enjoy it.......

If we are talking plain slice. Maybe a 6.3. I’m basing this score off their Sicilian and the reason I went. Good upside down square slice.

Sicilian slice only.

Very plain but good sauce and ingredients. Way too undercooked for me. Very doughy and no crunch. Let it cook a few minutes longer and score would be higher.

Bad pizza. Thick crust, bad crisp. Cheese couldn’t even cover the entire slice.

Too much dough, sauce isn’t bad though.

Superb. Ask for Tori!

Average slice here with some above average grease. It's good. (Bonus: Tomato slice - pretty good sauce. If you like sweet and tangy, you'll like this!)

I’ll tell ya what. Pizza joe has got it going on. From out of town visiting, and I can tell Nazareth is in good hands. Great slice, would recommend.

Best Sicilian out there period.

As close to a perfect pizza as you can get

Ok, I am a Sicilian Pie fan and this is one of the best I’ve had. It’s actually upside down style. Very legit and worth driving for!

Average slice.

Subpar pizza to be rivaled by carnival or mall pizza with service just as good as you'd get at the cvs across the street