Pizza Man's Pizza

This is my go to, somewhat local, pizza joint. We live about 35 minutes away, and frequently make the trip to get their pizza. Gotta order it cheese (even light cheese), well-done. Perfect under carriage, zero flop. The sauce is on the sweeter side; which I prefer. Pizza Man's Pizza have pretty much ruined local pizza for me. Pizza, pizza!

Easily the most disappointed I’ve been after opening a box. I thought I would like this pizza, so I got a large. Bad decision. The cheese was barely cooked on the pizza at all and was sliding all over the place. There’s a pool of sauce in the middle of the pizza. The sauce is sweet and not good. To be honest a 4.5 is an extremely high score for this train wreck of a pizza. It doesn’t help that one of the best spots in town is right next door either.

Awesome sauce. Great flavor on the dough. Super cheesy, maybe too cheesy. Only downfall is canned mushrooms, but I’ll be back for sure.

Beautiful undercarriage. The Buffalo sauce is easily a 9. It's homemade and so fresh. Tons of cheese and chicken. Easily a must try for Buffalo lovers.

My favorite pizza in Johnstown that I’ve tired. Not to much grease, cheese and sauce had great flavor along with some zest in the pepperoni. Will get again

Great crisp, sweet sauce, excellent pie.

Margarita pizza here. Solid crisp great undercarriage. Sauce is a little to sweet for me. With pepperoni it’s more well balanced. Some of the best crust around. Anyone saying santos is a 10 is delusional. That’s a review.

Very good pie!! I love the sweeter sauce here. Has some slight Westmont flop but that isn’t enough to lower the score for this beauty! Also love the pepperoni they use. That’s a review!!

I had 2 slices from the counter pie. It was fresh enough to serve as is but they threw it back in the oven anyways. The crust had a perfect snap to it but wasnt tough like others. The sauce was pretty bland, nothing I'd write home about. In my opinion the crust is what sets this pizza apart and is the reason I'll be back.

Small flop, good snap in the crust. Solid pie.

Very good, alot of flop. Highly recommend

Sweet sauce. A little bit of parm does a good touch. Pretty good pie

Margarita pizza is flame. Suggestion: order extra fresh mozzarella

Excellent pizza

Great flavor. Only negatives are a puddle of grease you’ll get and crust as dry as a potato chip. Really good pizza overall