Pizza Marvin

Great

Highly recommend if you are in the area. Crust is really good with a great choice of cheese. Less flop and this score could be even higher

This cheese pizza is a solid 8.8. Perfect crisp. Could use a bit more sauce. Can’t go wrong with this cheese. Place takes forever ever and is expensive. If you have time and money I’d recommend.

Pretty good crust, excellent pepperoni, sauce and cheese were frozen pizza bland. Wouldn’t make a special trip to come here but if you’re in Fox Point (I don’t recommend that) stop in.

Best pizza you’ll find in the state and it’s not even close.

While on a work trip, I decided to try the highest OB rated pizzas I could find. This one really lives up to the hype! This may be the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. A must try you won’t be disappointed.

House cheese pizza. Cooked to perfection fucking delicious. Barely any flop. Best pizza I’ve ever had. Made an account on here just to post this.

Solid ✌🏼

Accidentally ordered cheese-less pie. Would rate higher I think if I had ordered the standard slice

I went to all three famous locations in New Haven last week. Had to pick up a local pie. Simply on par with Sally’s at this point.

Outstanding piece in a great location. Great service to the table

All I needed was just one bite to tell you just how much I hate this place. First of all, why is my slice a square. The pizza was not advertised to me as a square. Secondly, apart from the loud metal music, and free trial of an nfl game being played on a projector, the staff was not friendly at all. Again, why was my slice a square? And why did it have 3 layers of pepperoni?

Good, not great.

Slice is more of a focaccia bread but sauce is unreal perfect level of sweet, did not put the slice down once

Great taste, heavy on the cheese and a little doughy. $36 for a cheese pizza with sausage is ridiculous.

Interesting slice. Hottest thing I’ve ever touched. Great dough