Was in Philly visiting my son and decided to try Shackamaxon. At first sight the pizza looked heavy but it wasn't. Pretty good flavor and a good amount of cheese. The tip flopped a little but not to bad. I don't mind a well done crust but this one was a little to well done to the point the crust just crumbled apart. For this reason I have to drop the score a little. The pie was $25. but the pizza was good enough to overlook the price. A pepperoni pie by me in the Bronx from a pizzeria that is rated 8.6 by barstool pizza is only $16.
Order now on Slice
Order Pizza Shackamaxon
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
bobby.gorman13/25/22, 6:01 p.m.
Massive slice wait for a pie was an hour had to get slices. Best crust on a pizza ive had
km0113/21/22, 10:40 a.m.
Pizza shackamaxon is currently ranked in the daily meals top 101 pizza places in the country and after one bite I could see why! I got a slice of their standard cheese and one of their upside down parmesan cheese as it was their daily special and was recommended by staff. Both slices were nothing short of amazing and were both easily in the 9's! Flavor was out of this world on both and the crisp was a legit 10 out of 10! Absolutely zero flop which is surprising considering the size of their slices! This is one of my highest scores overall in over 100 reviews and is currently my #1 rated slice and has set the bar very high for how good a reheated slice can be! Dave is out of his mind giving this one a 7.9! If this place had been around for generations or was located in New Haven or Boston he would have gone in the 9's without batting an eye!
mike.zachwieja3/5/22, 1:32 a.m.
Really solid pizza here. Good cheese to bread ratio in the beginning, but gets crispier the closer you get to the crust which is great. A couple big bubbles in these slices. Could use more sauce however, but always great that the wait isn’t long. Happy to continue bringing my business to Girard & Shackamaxon, good people working there as well.
aj.labella1/31/22, 5:34 a.m.
Second time having Shackamaxon. Crust is perfection. Very crispy again. Definitely a cheesier style and high quality. Cheese has a unique flavor. The sauce is the only thing keeping this from a perfect pizza. Little bland /not enough. Top 5 in Philly.
pizzasteve9/23/21, 11:31 p.m.
Unreal, one of the better slices I’ve had in my day!!! Incredible crisp limited flop very good Parmesan and flavors great ratio ruined my mouth skin
jason.ranieri8/13/21, 1:08 a.m.
great pie loved the tomato better nice and crispy great sauce
jonwong8/7/21, 8:29 p.m.
My favorite pizza shop in philly. It is hands down top of the top for me. The crust has a french baguette like quality to it. Huge fan, def must try