Pizza Social is by far the best pizza I have had in Florida! The thin crust gives it an artisan look/taste but is not floppy at all and the sauce complements it perfectly. All three pizzas we ordered were delicious and full of flavor, and my girlfriend said the salad was very fresh and delicious as well. They have the classic pizzas as well as some fun ones like a margherita and buffalo pizzas (BBQ chicken was my favorite). The shop itself gave off a small family beach shop feel and the employees were very friendly while we watched them make our pizzas. The owner even came out with his wife to introduce themselves and check on how our pizzas turned out. The oven looks really cool and cooked the pizzas in no time after we watched them being tossed in. My only complaint was the weekend traffic coming over the bridge to get to the place, but it was definitely worth it. I will for sure make a point to grab lunch there whenever I’m near the island so I can try some of the other pizzas off the big menu.
drew.betteridge12/23/22, 4:34 p.m.
Flop: 4 Cheese: 5 Crust: 8 Hold: 10 Sauce: 7 +1 for gluten free food and alcoholic beverage options.
nick.christakos10/26/22, 2:38 p.m.
Great find. Crust had great crisp with some chew. Sauce was very good and not overbearing. Great cheese and it was cooked perfect. Staff was very nice too.
devin.luckett7/26/22, 1:42 a.m.
Good taste, cool spot! Crust is crispy but the rest of the pizza is not.
k.w263/9/22, 4:09 p.m.
Very well cooked, good undercarriage and good tasting crust. Nice sauce to cheese ratio and spicy pepperoni. Best on AMI?
erixmith1/16/22, 8:39 p.m.
Good flavor, good music and the crust is good but could use more crispness.
christina.mommsen1/16/22, 8:37 p.m.
I like frozen pizza better. It’s super basic. Nothing special at all about it. But nice people!
aidensmitty241/16/22, 8:35 p.m.
First is very good and I like the cheese and sauce too. It is pretty crispy and very fresh. Good pizza
joe.stafford27/25/21, 12:05 a.m.
Much better than it looks! Stringy cheese and sweet sauce!!!
mgrimm2_3/19/21, 1:24 a.m.
Got two pies, margarita and “Beach Please” which was basically chicken bacon ranch. Flat 7 rookie score for both because it’s definitely not a 6 but can’t be higher for what we got. The toppings and sauce were great. The top was cooked pretty much perfect but the bottom of the pizza was way underdone. It wasn’t raw but it just had no crisp on the bottom at all. If it wasn’t for that this would be a mid 7 easily
jeremiah.haili2/17/21, 7:40 p.m.
Great owners. Private business. No commercial business on the island. Husband and wife owner. Love these guys !
matthew.kimberly1/4/21, 3:18 a.m.
Good pizza and cooked perfectly. Nice undercarriage. Just greasy