Place is solid overall. Sauce to cheese ratio was on point, nice crust, but wasn't crispy enough. Would have gave scored the same as their other location.
Order now on Slice
Order Pizza Station
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
bigdaddytom879/12/22, 10:20 p.m.
This high score is for the BBQ chicken slice pictured here. It's got tender, juicy chicken and the sweet kind of BBQ sauce I'm addicted to! The best one I personally had. To be fair, I did have a regular slice too, which is a solid 7.0 with great crust, 0 flop whatsoever and good sauce and cheese ratio! Easily the best in Katonah.
mike_h.nyc8/24/21, 11:21 p.m.
Very big slice haven’t had the pie. Average cheese slice but the cheese is very good. Solid doughy crust.
pizzavore5/29/21, 10:54 p.m.
1 cheese slice and 1 BBQ chicken slice, 2:50pm on a Friday, $7.58 Score is on the cheese slice only Pros: Fantastic cook, taste and ratio at this Northern Westchester train stop pizzeria. Cons: No complaints Verdict: Sauce cheese and dough is so simple but in the right combination and cooked the right way, it can be amazing. A lot of standard pizza places, even in Westchester, don't hit the sweet spot. This slice today nailed it. Next time maybe the reheat doesn't get pulled at just the right time or maybe this was an outlier lucky slice. I've scored slices ridiculously high before only to go back and get something just above average. Today this is a high 7's, best you can hope for from your local. Extra credit for a killer slice close to 3pm. The BBQ slice was piled high with fat, saucy chicken bites. Sauce reminded me of Stew Leonard's BBQ, or another favorite. Was a bit too messy with the chicken chunks rolling over my hands as I tried to drive an oversized vehicle. I probably should have pulled over
carter.gross5/17/21, 7:34 p.m.
Solid NY flop pizza. Sauce was lacking flavor. Better than La Familia down the street.
shawn.coffta8/12/20, 12:27 p.m.
If it was a little less greasy this would have received an even higher score. This is the best I've had so far. If I lived near hear I would end up turning into a pepperoni. Great slice.
jackson.moreo7/20/19, 9:06 p.m.
Decent slice, some flop and the pizza is cheesy, not the best but the crust is much better
will.moreo7/20/19, 9:00 p.m.
Best slice in Katonah ❌🧢. Not to die for but a solid slice. Thin with a nice crust, 7 5.
mr.mozzerella6/25/19, 7:47 p.m.
Flopped so bad half the Mozzarella fell off. This slice is best eaten after it cools down a bit. When it’s out of the oven, it has no personality. There is no cohesion. Everything sits there and does its own thing. Good Mozzarella, good crust & dough. The sauce tastes like thick tomato water that is allergic to seasoning. What a shame.
mikeynoodz8/29/18, 11:13 p.m.
Perfect if you say well done (you’re a rookie pizza person if you don’t ) also some of the best speciality slices in westchester county