Pizza Suprema

This might be another place that probably would score higher with a fresh pie. These reheated slices were just bland average pizza to me. Nothing really offensive and nothing really spectacular.

Decent pizza. Floppy and no crisp though even when asked to cook it slightly more well done. Nice staff

Decent pizza, good flavor This is a good everyday slice!

Solid pizza! Plenty of toppings. Could’ve been a little more done in my opinion. But, good overall pie. Enjoy!

I’ve been to over 20-30 pizza spots and this is one of the best in Tampa by far

Good crunch. A little greasy but solid pizza

Best local pizza joint and my go to in the Lutz/Land O Lakes area. Don’t get any of their pies with loads of toppings and such on it. A single topping or plain cheese 18” pie cooked well done is the way to go. It’s truly in the 8.1-8.3 range when done correctly and high 7s when it isn’t. You can never go wrong ordering from here.

Decent pizza. The crust is a little thick. Best pizza in the area.

The Palermo slice this is by far the best pizza in town, it has the best crust If you're looking for perfection I found it. Give it a try you won't be disappointed.

Always pretty good pizza

Hard to find a better pizza than this in Tampa

Above average football pizza. The owners are from the New York area so they know what to do in terms of delivering a solid NYC slice.

Great service. Tony and Sajeed were great. Solid pizza. Little crunch. Not much grease. Good cheese to sauce ratio. Best slice I’ve had around the lutz/land o lakes area. ($3.05 for 1 Lg slice)

Nice slice...a little on the cheesy side for me which creates some grease and flop...good crust but needs more sauce. Good slice

Good taste. Not too much grease. Crisp crust

Excellent NY style pizza! Love the vibe of the place (outside of the no AC thing) as well! Very kind/cool staff that delivers the pizza to your table with a “made with love” quote! Highly recommended! Excellent pizza!!!! Try these folks out, you will be very happy you did! :)

Very cheesy, very doughy, kind of messy. Not a bad pizza though

Good pizza. I would recommend it. Good flop, crust is crispy, sauce is decent

Eh, it’s alright. It’s like the Die Hard 2 of pizza. You’re not gonna say it’s bad mostly because you don’t remember it. Boom. That’s your review.