Pizza Supreme

This place has put it all together on this cheese pie best flavor finally meets legit undercarriage. This place can be on par with anywhere in state. The large cheese pizza get it ur welcome

Slight amount of crunch, nice undercarriage, and pretty good sauce. A little too much oil. A little less oil and a little more crunch would put this into the low 8’s, which would be a spectacular score. Overall, pretty good pizza.

Pizza was a little flimsy, but still good.

Was not appealing at first. But looks can be deceiving. Great sauce flavor, great amount of cheese and the crust was just right.

Looking for a bit of a more crunch sauce is decent. Good overall pie.

Perfect amount of sauce. A little cheesier than I like. A little greasy. Great crust. Best pizza in this area

Solid pizza. Quite a bit of flop. If they could get it crispy this could be in the 8’s.

Find me pizza better than The Supreme One.

Pretty Good Pizza Probably The Best In This Area

This is good camp pizza. Did the trick on a rainy day. Would definitely go back.

Pretty mediocre pie to be honest. Pretty much everything screams low quality football pizza. Very greasy, very floppy, noticeably salty, too much sauce too much cheese, too much tang. I ordered this pie well done, while it had more char it was still a mega flop. It’s not awful but I’d expect more from a long standing family run spot in NY. It’s basically the pizza you would find in Anytown, USA

A little to doughy for my liking. There was absolutely no crunch but the sauce wasn’t bad at all. Barley any grease so I assume they’re using quality cheese which definitely helps the overall flavor of the pie.

The best your going to get around here

Truly a first..... I asked for 2 slices (at 2:45 on a Saturday afternoon) and was told "we don't have any cheese slices". I asked if a pie would be coming out and they said "no it's been busy today". Let's face it, around here you can serve Wonder Bread with ketchup and American Cheese and call it pizza...... very few choices...... but you gotta offer something.