I've been a Broadway Joe's boy for a while when it comes to pizza by Manhattan College, but this is good fucking pizza. My slices were hot out of oven with the right amount of char on the bottom, crispy crust, and good sauce. Definitely recommend. I'll be back again soon to try out their specialty slices
silvsdaddy11/21/19, 6:02 p.m.
Solid slice no doubt. As a Manhattan College student and Horace Mann employee I’m around these streets a lot 😤😤😤😤. Far above broadway joes and goodfellas. That’s a fact Jack.
dylan.flores9/29/19, 11:45 p.m.
Alright Frankie, here’s the review for pizza supreme, for the cheese slice we got a solid 8.2. Almost no flop, good crust and a really good sauce. A little bit of grease but not too much. Definitely a good slice
bato9/24/19, 1:58 a.m.
Much better than the regular slice, sauce not sweet good tomato taste, cheese fresh
jerseyjuice5/9/19, 4:46 p.m.
Slices were good. A little greasy and just tiny bit undercooked. The sauce was very good though. Crust was average. I sense that this could be an awesome slice and wanna come back to see if that is true. The staff was very friendly. I’ll be here next time I’m around.
daniel.gilman4/15/19, 4:31 p.m.
Happy surprised by the quality of the slice. Very little flop and lots of sauce
nick.gazzillo1/23/19, 5:26 p.m.
Really solid slice. Great dough and crust, flavorful cheese, and rich sauce.
jjjjjcjvjsjwjf1/23/19, 5:21 p.m.
Bomb new pizza joint. Reasonable slice price and great specialty slices. Dough has great flavor and sauce in on point.
pizzaboy93848391/14/19, 11:28 p.m.
I write this review as "Let it be" plays on the speakers and as pizza supreme stands currently, you should Let it be. From the outside Pizza Supreme looks beautiful. The pizza? Not so hot. Compared to other local shops such as Broadway Joe's this pizza lacks flavor and creativity. In conclusion, get Broadway Joe's, a 10 second walk from Pizza Supreme