Top Restaurants

Pizza Supreme

678 Stewart Ave, Garden City, NY

Pizza Review

1 like

frank.reese on One Bite Pizza App

frank.reese

7/21/24 4:03 PM

OK, here we are, another football camp with my son. And another pizza review. Looks pretty good. Probably typical Long Island pizza. Lets get into it. So the looks could be deceiving, pizza is just OK at best. Sauce is just so so, cheese is just so so, and the crust could use some work. Not your average Long Island pizza I could tell you that much.

Order Pizza Supreme

Hungry? Order right now on Slice

Order now on Slice

Pizza Review

anthony.palmieri211/21/24, 5:18 p.m.

6.7

A little bland tasting but very crisp, noticeable crisp in every bite. I really liked the place, the staff was kind, and the prices were pretty fair. They’re supposedly more known for their square which was good, gave the square a 7.6. I probably would come back it’s a good neighborhood spot.

Pizza Review

luis.de jesus19/5/24, 4:46 p.m.

7.2

Pizza Review

sammykush2/17/24, 12:12 a.m.

7.5

Picture doesn’t do it justice because it’s actually very good. Solid NY slice. Nothing crazy, but very very good. Would get again for sure.

Pizza Review

dan.opallo10/11/23, 1:21 p.m.

9.0

The best square slice around. Like Rizzo’s of Astoria, from when I was growing up, but elevated. The sauce is perfect. Lots of cheese, but it stays put the whole way through.

Pizza Review

steve.hudsons1/26/23, 3:40 a.m.

1.9

This is a carbon copy of ellios frozen pizza. Even the undercarriage is identical.

Pizza Review

jared.dominguez8/31/22, 5:14 p.m.

7.8

Solid crunch, bit saucy

Pizza Review

pizza-pusher7/29/21, 8:45 p.m.

7.1

Good, but not as good as it was going back 20 years, but nothing really is. The crisp is excellent, the sauce is a little mild, cheese is good with a little bit of grease. Would I drive out of my way for it….no if I’m in the area and wanted pizza then yes

Pizza Review

mcrobrez17/28/21, 2:24 a.m.

6.8

Go for the little guy!!!! If it wasn’t for the little guy square slice, I would say pass on this spot. The little guy was crunchy, nice taste and the sauce was delicious. The regular slice on the other hand was oily, smelly, excessive crust and just not very good.

Pizza Review

avadolce7/9/21, 6:30 p.m.

8.4

This is an all time favorite. Sauce is great, cheese is great, crust is great, never really any complaints. FIYAH

Pizza Review

humble-tavern1/24/21, 1:20 a.m.

7.8

Good for around here

Pizza Review

softsoap1/20/21, 6:32 p.m.

6.2

Not bad it’s decent it’s drunk pizza

Pizza Review

t-rex.pizza10/31/20, 7:16 p.m.

7.9

About as solid as is gets. Great flavor and crisp. Cheese to sauce ratio was spot on and worth stop for any pizza lover.

Pizza Review

anthony.celano9/23/20, 4:00 a.m.

7.9

A lot of people get it a lot don’t. Pizza supreme is known for their square slice many moons ago they were in Roosevelt Field. It’s definitely a unique slice . Don’t even bother getting a regular slice. Get the square!!!

Pizza Review

charles.tetro2/24/20, 4:53 a.m.

7.6

Solid regular slice (7.6) football pizza though a bit greasy. The square slice (7.4) was a bit dry & doesn’t compare to grandma pizza elsewhere.

Pizza Review

sgt.pizza2/11/20, 4:42 p.m.

5.5

Regular: decent cook on dough, it's a decent tasting slice but messy and greasy 5.5 Sicilan: this slice is a joke I wouldn't be surprised if it's a frozen pizza it seriously tastes that way. Definitely the worst sicilan I've ever had 2.4

Pizza Review

kyle.smith102/1/20, 5:17 p.m.

7.9

Pizza Review

anton.lavelo1/9/20, 5:59 p.m.

6.4

Solid... not exceptional. Sauce on square tastes like its canned.

Pizza Review

trevor.dorfman12/15/19, 8:26 p.m.

8.9

Amazing square pie

Pizza Review

tyler.nemjo12/7/19, 5:08 p.m.

8.5

Pizza crust is firm and it tastes delicious. One bite only, everyone knows the rules!

Pizza Review

sko.isles10/10/19, 8:18 p.m.

8.3

Pizza Review

chris.antonacci18/1/19, 5:35 p.m.

8.1

The small square pizza is legendary good sauce good cheese small ez to eat lite crust great taste a must have pizza

Pizza Review

marc.ambrosino5/16/19, 11:34 p.m.

8.9

Very delicious, Sicilian pie.

Pizza Review

pastortickles5/8/19, 10:36 p.m.

8.3

Square Pie is to die for

Pizza Review

michael.john64/15/19, 3:44 p.m.

6.0

Great but sauce