Top Restaurants

Pizza Supreme

19070 La Puente Rd, West Covina, CA

Pizza Review

3 likes

pizzaontheroof on One Bite Pizza App

pizzaontheroof

3/17/21 2:57 AM

One bite. Everybody knows the rules. Solid pie from “Pizza Supreme.” Perfect crunch all throughout the undercarriage and crust. Cheese has got very distinct flavor, and none of that curdy nonsense. Consistency was spot-on. Sauce had a great balance of tangy, sweet, and savory. Everything you could want in a pie. All inclusive. Honestly comparable to the few NY pizza joints I’ve eaten at. We enjoyed every last bite. That’s a review.

Order Pizza Supreme

Hungry? Order right now on Slice

Order now on Slice

Pizza Review

bobby.martinez13/21/24, 7:48 p.m.

7.9

Very delicious the meat lover. For me I wish it had more crisp on the bite. Maybe 5-10 mins in the oven would have gave it that 8. Something.

Pizza Review

felipe.campos5/1/22, 7:45 p.m.

7.1

One thing I love about pizza places is the atmosphere. My girl and I walked in and 2 customers greeted the owner rolling the dough in the back. Locals talking to the owner, that’s a good sign. We ordered the meat lovers (I know not a gold metal slice but I was on a date with my girl). Pizza almost melted my face off, but it looks like the 80’s in here, and probably hasn’t changed since which is a plus. 7.1, little bit too doughy, this is a great pie.

Pizza Review

jesse.sanchez48/29/21, 11:43 p.m.

8.3

Great undercarriage crispy! The flavor is great football pizza. It’s doughy yet crispy at the same time! The sauce is nice and the cheese is high quality. I’m not one for crust and I’ll eat this! Everyone else with me gave a 8.5 but honestly 8.3 for me is the highest I’ve given out for a pie so that’s saying something. Definitely need to check this out Davey!

Pizza Review

darrian2/15/20, 4:22 a.m.

6.7

Major flop. Quality sauce and cheese. Very average crust. Nothing too special about the place.

Pizza Review

pizza_junkie12/30/19, 2:13 a.m.

7.9

A little flop, cheese held on though. Generous portion of cheese. High-quality mozzarella. Sauce has a nice tang and is nicely proportioned. Crisp, light crust. Really good crust. Solid pie. Best I’ve had in SGV, so far. 7.9, that’s the review.

Pizza Review

neenyo12/4/18, 5:17 a.m.

9.1

Perfect crunch, tasty sauce, good fucking pizza right here👌