Pizza Thief

Cute try at New York Style. Picked it up right at our order time. Crust was bland and soggy. Sauce was decent, cheese was almost flavorless. Huge dissapoinment

Very delicious pizza! The slice wasn’t even that expensive. The pepperoni was perfectly spicy and you could definitely taste the cheese and sauce. The only “bad”thing about this pizza is that it is very thin and the whole pizza is very expensive.

Great crust sourdough! Crunchy crust

Good pizza! The best slice is definitely the cheese. Good undercarriage, good crunch, perfect amount of sauce. Very good slice all the way around. When I come back I will only be sticking with the cheese. I struggled with the other two.

This is some of the best pizza in Portland. The bread/crust is fantastic, although not super crispy if that’s what you’re looking for. The sauce and the cheese have great flavor. It’s hard to put together why this pizza is as good as it is, it just is!

Great crunch! Nice undercarriage. Flavor packed, but a bit too greasy for my liking. Nonetheless a solid pizza

A must visit place in Portland and probably the best overall pizza shop in portland. Phenomenal pizza with many different flavors and seasonal pies as well as delicious cookies, and salads.

Great slice. No flop, good cheese, not too oily. I don’t know anything about dough but you can tell they do something a little different, has a sourdough taste. Great spot with a cool little bar attached.

This is a very good by the slice place. Maybe the best in town for slices. Quality ingredients and a good crust.

If there was more sauce we’d be looking at a HUGE score. Super light and crispy with barely any grease

Pretty decent New York style pizza. Tastes remarkably similar to Apizza Scholls.

Pup trying to be the new mascot for pizza thief

Super thin, very crispy. Quality ingredients. Flavorful sauce and cheese, but not nearly enough choose as I'd have liked. Also, maybe slightly too well done (there was no "pull" on the cheese). Some of the best pepperonis I've had in a very long time, though.

Great crunch, sauce and cheese a little flop

This is about as perfect as a slice of Pepp can be. Could be Americas best Pepp slice, and yes ive been to NYC

Great atmosphere, very friendly staff. Pizza by the Slice. Very unique style slices. Suggest mushroom and potatoe/onion slices.

Solid za had barely any flop, perfect sauce cheese ratio all around, seems to be seasoned as well if you like that. Crust was crisp on the outside and fluffy inside. One of the best of portland

Could’ve gone 8.1, but going with the score because there was a bit too much char. Good Crisp and strong tang on the cheese, The sauce made no impact. I’m pretty reliable slice for this area of the country.

Great crust. Good flavor to sauce.

Pepperoni, Cheese and Hot Tony are on point. The crust is amazing.