Pizza Time

It was okay pizza. It was decent for the area but compared to NY pizza it wasn’t anything to write home about. Style was practically NY pizza which is why the place was popular but crust on traditional was overcooked.

So hungry ate the pizza before taking a pic… great pizza little pricey but you get what you pay for.

They left our slice in a little too long. Otherwise, everything about this place and this slice felt like pizza by the slice in the northeast

Plain cheese had solid undercarriage, minimal flop and good cheese hold. Sauce was a bit underwhelming and not a lot of flavor. This would be a bit above average if we’re comparing to an NYC dollar slice. The star of the show was the caprese Sicilian style slice. Good crunch and complex flavor. The crust was incredibly flavorful. I’ve also had the grandmas pizza in the past and it’s a winner. Two slices and a Pepsi was $20 bucks and that was after a 10 minute wait just to get in. Worth it? If you’re already on St. George street give it a try. Cheese Slice: 7.1 Caprese: 8.2

Great slice, would be an 8.1 but I like a little more sauce. One of the best pizzas I’ve had.

Gramma’s pizza was spot on (7.7) A solid slice and very flavorful sauce and crust. The regular was not as impressed. The dough was lacking flavor and body. (6.9). Garlic rolls were old and honestly not even worth ranking… would never have those again.

Pizzas ok for the area but the claim of US 2nd best is a stretch

About as good as pizza gets in Florida.

Got the pepp and margharita couldn’t wait. So good.

Pizza is a bit greasy, not as much taste as I thought it would have. Proclaims to be the 2nd best pizza in the USA. I can not concur, good but not great pizza.

It’s a real tasting NY pizza, got regular and Sicilian slice. Very good, good crust, good dough and cheese. Cooked perfect. If they were fresh out of the oven the score would be higher. But will definitely grab a slice every time I’m around here.

SAUCE! CRUST!!! and the team making the pizza were awesome! 8.1 Frankie

Grandmas slice 7.1 white 6.1 coming from a fan of white. All in all the thicker pizza is better than the thin 6.5 overall on the place. Not horrible but not amazing.

Pizza was decent Garlic rolls were amazing 7.9 !!!

By the slice. Quality cheese, no flop, with strong undercarriage. 💪

Underwhelming and overhyped. Sauce has zero pop

Probably the best football style pizza place I’ve been to in FL. Nice undercarriage, no flop. Crust is too dense.

Great sauce. Good crispy crust.