Pizza Time

Slices are OKAY. Dough is to thick to be considered a N.Y. Slice. Definitely overpriced as well.. $43.56 for 4 pepperoni slices ($4.50 a slice) and 2 small salads and 2 fountain drinks.. Correct pricing not posted online and it’s not posted in the restaurant.. Flavors were decent but still underwhelming.. It’s cash only but they don’t tell you that until it’s time to pay

Seems pretty authentic. Cheese to sauce ratio is on point. Crust lacks a bit of taste but flop is just right. 7.9.

Underwhelming and overhyped. Sauce has zero pop

Pizza was a 6 but just the cleanest was nasty. The sign say “Second best pizza” had a huge spider on the sign. Wish I knew before ordering.

For St. Augustine, outstanding pizza. Cheese + sauce are a beautiful combo.

Very good pizza. Could of been cooked longer but I did just get a slice. Crust was great with great flavor. People inside were very nice and all their pizza looked fantastic. I highly recommend stopping in for a quick slice.

Not the famous slice but not terrible

Great pizza. A joke that it was 2nd best in US. They definitely rip off tourists

Insane! Especially the Sicilian!

Good not great. nice thin slice good dough

Very tasty. Would get a slice there anytime. Only real knock is that the slices are so big, it is hard to get a good crisp throughout

Slightly above avg pizza ... looks like they need to update this ranking, lol

Crispy crust... cheese justtttttt right! 8.3 ALL DAY! A Dave Portnoy must stop spot in FLA!

Cheese pizza not pictured crispy throughout great place

The pepperoni slice was very crispy and good flavor (7.8). I’m not a thick crust person but the grandmas slice was surprisingly good with sweet sauce (7.4).

Incredible crispy and fluffy crust, super fresh tomatoes, great cheese. Fantastic pizza, great owner!

Grandma’s Slice. #2 Pizza in the U.S. according to TripAdvisor. Great sauce and fluffy crust. In a extra good mood because the guy behind the counter hates Joe Biden.

I know it’s a rookie score, but it’s great pizza. Nothing wrong with it at all. Grandmas Slice is Amazing. All the others looked great too. Best pizza in NE FL.

Hell of a pizza place here, right in the middle of downtown St. Augustine. This place has got some good looking pies in the window. The pizza screams quality ingredients. It had a good ratio of sauce and cheese, medium flop, and decent crisp. It is just short of an 8 but I think perhaps Pizza Time is known a bit better for their specialty styles. This golden slice lands on 7.9. That's a review.

Chicken Parm-8.1. Very crispy and great crunch to it. Very good overall. I’ve had the pepperoni before and I’d give that a 8.3. Grandma slice- 7.6 This isn’t there traditional grandma slice that one is far more superior. This was a little too saucy for me but overall solid.

Delicious Pizza.

So many great options.

The Grandma’s slice is definitely their flagship. With good reason. The cheese, sauce, and drizzled olive oil form a mosaic of pizza goodness.