First it’s F’n HOT. Strong crisp crust. Maybe too crisp it cracked in half. Strong tomato taste to sauce. Cheese was nothing special. Pretty greasy. Sign says 2nd best pizza in America. You better have game to state that. Took a couple points for that statement.
scott.wilson178/21/21, 5:21 p.m.
By the slice. Quality cheese, no flop, with strong undercarriage. 💪
pizzaandbeer7/20/21, 11:24 p.m.
Probably the best football style pizza place I’ve been to in FL. Nice undercarriage, no flop. Crust is too dense.
craig.edwards25/11/21, 10:27 p.m.
Slices are OKAY. Dough is to thick to be considered a N.Y. Slice. Definitely overpriced as well.. $43.56 for 4 pepperoni slices ($4.50 a slice) and 2 small salads and 2 fountain drinks.. Correct pricing not posted online and it’s not posted in the restaurant.. Flavors were decent but still underwhelming.. It’s cash only but they don’t tell you that until it’s time to pay
ryan.michaels14/28/21, 4:25 p.m.
Seems pretty authentic. Cheese to sauce ratio is on point. Crust lacks a bit of taste but flop is just right. 7.9.
william444/8/21, 8:27 p.m.
Pizza was a 6 but just the cleanest was nasty. The sign say “Second best pizza” had a huge spider on the sign. Wish I knew before ordering.
nicorico3214/3/21, 2:24 a.m.
For St. Augustine, outstanding pizza. Cheese + sauce are a beautiful combo.
matt.pittenger3/19/21, 10:37 p.m.
Very good pizza. Could of been cooked longer but I did just get a slice. Crust was great with great flavor. People inside were very nice and all their pizza looked fantastic. I highly recommend stopping in for a quick slice.
robert.skovholt2/18/21, 8:53 p.m.
Great pizza. A joke that it was 2nd best in US. They definitely rip off tourists
mark.rapp1/30/21, 6:35 p.m.
Very tasty. Would get a slice there anytime. Only real knock is that the slices are so big, it is hard to get a good crisp throughout