Good crunch, no flop, good sauce and nice amount of cheese. A little greasy but excellent slice. Grandma slice not bad either.
ryan.michaels14/28/21, 4:25 p.m.
Seems pretty authentic. Cheese to sauce ratio is on point. Crust lacks a bit of taste but flop is just right. 7.9.
william444/8/21, 8:27 p.m.
Pizza was a 6 but just the cleanest was nasty. The sign say “Second best pizza” had a huge spider on the sign. Wish I knew before ordering.
nicorico3214/3/21, 2:24 a.m.
For St. Augustine, outstanding pizza. Cheese + sauce are a beautiful combo.
matt.pittenger3/19/21, 10:37 p.m.
Very good pizza. Could of been cooked longer but I did just get a slice. Crust was great with great flavor. People inside were very nice and all their pizza looked fantastic. I highly recommend stopping in for a quick slice.
robert.skovholt2/18/21, 8:53 p.m.
Great pizza. A joke that it was 2nd best in US. They definitely rip off tourists
mark.rapp1/30/21, 6:35 p.m.
Very tasty. Would get a slice there anytime. Only real knock is that the slices are so big, it is hard to get a good crisp throughout
nelly361/2/21, 4:31 p.m.
Slightly above avg pizza ... looks like they need to update this ranking, lol
6 views•0 likes
jeff.ohara12/30/20, 4:46 a.m.
Crispy crust... cheese justtttttt right! 8.3 ALL DAY! A Dave Portnoy must stop spot in FLA!
cody.spears12/21/20, 5:40 p.m.
The pepperoni slice was very crispy and good flavor (7.8). I’m not a thick crust person but the grandmas slice was surprisingly good with sweet sauce (7.4).
texfischer11/21/20, 5:16 p.m.
Incredible crispy and fluffy crust, super fresh tomatoes, great cheese. Fantastic pizza, great owner!
jonathon.stack11/21/20, 5:14 p.m.
Grandma’s Slice. #2 Pizza in the U.S. according to TripAdvisor. Great sauce and fluffy crust. In a extra good mood because the guy behind the counter hates Joe Biden.
thomas.hern11/21/20, 5:13 p.m.
I know it’s a rookie score, but it’s great pizza. Nothing wrong with it at all. Grandmas Slice is Amazing. All the others looked great too. Best pizza in NE FL.
tmooney10/18/20, 4:15 p.m.
Hell of a pizza place here, right in the middle of downtown St. Augustine. This place has got some good looking pies in the window. The pizza screams quality ingredients. It had a good ratio of sauce and cheese, medium flop, and decent crisp. It is just short of an 8 but I think perhaps Pizza Time is known a bit better for their specialty styles. This golden slice lands on 7.9. That's a review.
keith.lovett10/12/20, 6:05 a.m.
Chicken Parm-8.1. Very crispy and great crunch to it. Very good overall. I’ve had the pepperoni before and I’d give that a 8.3. Grandma slice- 7.6 This isn’t there traditional grandma slice that one is far more superior. This was a little too saucy for me but overall solid.
robby.wander7/25/20, 2:21 a.m.
The Grandma’s slice is definitely their flagship. With good reason. The cheese, sauce, and drizzled olive oil form a mosaic of pizza goodness.