texfischer11/21/20, 5:16 p.m.
Incredible crispy and fluffy crust, super fresh tomatoes, great cheese. Fantastic pizza, great owner!
jonathon.stack11/21/20, 5:14 p.m.
Grandma’s Slice. #2 Pizza in the U.S. according to TripAdvisor. Great sauce and fluffy crust. In a extra good mood because the guy behind the counter hates Joe Biden.
thomas.hern11/21/20, 5:13 p.m.
I know it’s a rookie score, but it’s great pizza. Nothing wrong with it at all. Grandmas Slice is Amazing. All the others looked great too. Best pizza in NE FL.
tmooney10/18/20, 4:15 p.m.
Hell of a pizza place here, right in the middle of downtown St. Augustine. This place has got some good looking pies in the window. The pizza screams quality ingredients. It had a good ratio of sauce and cheese, medium flop, and decent crisp. It is just short of an 8 but I think perhaps Pizza Time is known a bit better for their specialty styles. This golden slice lands on 7.9. That's a review.
keith.lovett10/12/20, 6:05 a.m.
Chicken Parm-8.1. Very crispy and great crunch to it. Very good overall. I’ve had the pepperoni before and I’d give that a 8.3. Grandma slice- 7.6 This isn’t there traditional grandma slice that one is far more superior. This was a little too saucy for me but overall solid.
robby.wander7/25/20, 2:21 a.m.
The Grandma’s slice is definitely their flagship. With good reason. The cheese, sauce, and drizzled olive oil form a mosaic of pizza goodness.
joe.ruppert7/11/20, 11:37 p.m.
Great crisp, needs more sauce, cheese is decent. Will be back. That’s a review
joe.libero7/1/20, 7:30 p.m.
This is the Grandma pie slice. It’s the greatest thing you will ever eat. If you are in St Augustine. You gotta go. The taste is mind blowing. Dominic the owner will take care of you It is so f**king good.
lou.cacio3/2/20, 9:32 p.m.
This is my TOP RATED PIZZA in Florida! Expect a line out front, cash only and be ready order. This place NEVER disappoints. Enjoy! 😎
mmmpr3s2/14/20, 9:59 p.m.
Got a lot of stuff to try, the burrata Sicilian style was the best! Everything else was delicious as usual as well. Someone needs to tell Dave to come try this place!
mackmanco1bite2/12/20, 8:15 p.m.
Decent pie. Too much cheese and not enough sauce. A ton of St. Augustine flop. Underdone and doughy. Not worth makin a trip for it; but if you’re in that neck of the woods and u want a solid slice, check em out