Pizza Toni

This is solid pizza. It surprised me. It has a Papa Gino's vibe, and that is a good thing. A legit 8 pizza

Best in Montreal. Closest to New Haven pizza.

One of my favourite slices of all time. The square slices are really good too but the regular New York style takes the cake.

Best pizza in Montreal. Get the garlic pepperoni pizza with hot honey

Bonjour hi I may have lowballed this place, the crust was pretty good, but for me, the lack of balance knocks it down. Oregano cheese sauce, etc. don’t really fall into proportion as well as they should. Probably low sevens if you get it fresh.

Great pizza! I’ve tried a ton of pizza this past week and this one is by FAR the best in Montreal. Very close to a NY slice. Thin. Crisp. Well done and charred a bit which adds a nice touch. Cheese selection could have been better and push this guy into the high 8s/low 9s. I also had the pizza a bit cold, which I’m sure hurt the score. Overall fantastic pizza. You won’t regret your order!

Incredible pizza. Get the ranch and hot honey!

This is Vesta 2.0. Vesta turned to shit overnight because the guy making it went to pizza Toni, I’m sure. It’s not exactly the same. Not the same ingredients and all, but the recipe is the same. This is the heavyweight champion now

"Alright Frankie, pizza review time! Rumor has it that this place uses the same pepperonis as the world famous Prince Street Pizza in NYC. If this doesn't taste like a New York pizza — I don't know what coulda woulda shoulda. Alright Frankie, one bite, everyone knows the rules... Wow! Good taste, no flop. This is a solid New York style pizza Frankie! No rookie score here, Mr Toni really studied his New York slice. One bite of this could make Alicia Keys say she's in 🎶 NEW YORK! 🎶. Imma give it a 8.5 Frankie! Huge score!"

Hard to find a better quick slice let’s be real

Good pizza and a good price for it. A little doughy but nice and crispy. Love the charred taste underneath the pizza.