Pizza Undici

Crispiest bottom of any pie on the Island. No flop.

Ordered a regular and sicilian. Looked like some nice thick sicilians in the case....and instead...was given a grandma. Under $7 for 2 slices not bad at all. Lots of specialty slices here also and they all look good. The regular would be a portnoy mid 8....if the sauce wasnt so damn sweet. Super thin, great under, great crust, solid cheese. The sauce ruins it though. The "sicilian" / grandma was solid. Thin and crispy. Sauce was different from the regular and definitely better. Was weird though because there was crisp...but floppy. Since they screwed up my order and i cant rate my normal Sicilian, im gonna average the other 2 and call it a day 8.1 on the regular 7.6 on the grandma

sauce so sweet hurts your teeth

Been driving about 15-20 minutes a week (sometimes twice a week) for these slices all summer. Incredible variety and everything tastes perfectly on par. Obsessed with the upside down slice currently. Definitely one of the best spots on the island.

Thin, crispy, and good specialty slices. Better than a lot of LI pizza, but not quite in the 8’s

Best pie on Long Island

Very good regular slice. Thin and crisp.Only tried one regular slice but enjoyed it