Pizza Village

Holy crap does this suck. Blade and Salt was closed, and John’s drive in was packed. Had to eat “something” quick. Jarred sauce taste, cheese barely melted. Why is this place still in business? Cause of people like me who just need some sort of food? Garbage.

My favorite pizza, was unfortunately disappointing , idk what happened, again the sauce is awesome however the Dow was way to thick for the slice, not enough sauce and cheese on it, then it would have been a 8.8, but I did not enjoy it at all, they changed it up, don’t fix a chair that’s not broken

Very good dough tastes better than it looks

Soooo good but soooo greasy! 🍕

Best pizza in montauk

Floppy super thin slice, I’ve had so many good slices in the past here, maybe it was an off day because it is winter idk. Very nice staff.

Plain and basic, the late night drunk pizza of Montauk. Floppy, no thrills.

Ehhhhh lowkey floppy, greasy, and more floppy. I think if I wasn’t starving when I ate this slice I would have given it a lower score lmaoo. The sauce and cheese weren’t half bad, the shits just couldn’t even stay in my hand it was so floppy. Prob good drunk pizza tho

Great ratio all around. Not greasy, light on cheese with good crisp. Would like to try fresh pie

Extreme flop, a little greasy, and ridiculously thin. Sauce and cheese had a nice flavor but crust was too doughy. If it was left in a tad longer it’s an easy 7+

Pizza was great . Crispy Crust and tasty sauce. It’s the Only place in Montauk open year round . But Always my go to spot when I take a trip out to Montauk.

Not very good. This pizza was as cold as the snow on the ground. Perhaps it’s because of the offseason but still..

Solid slice