Pizza Wagon

As a Brooklyn native, Pizza Wagon is a go to spot. Even during a hot summer day, the fresh slice was still great to the taste. Super thin, enjoyable crust and savory cheese were all positives for the slice. But one thing it did lack in was an above average sauce. Being mediocre at best, the sauce definitely hindered the slice.

Had bad intentions for this slice after ordering a pie a few years ago. After revisiting this disaster-class, this slice by Pizza Wagon shocked me. This singular slice was airy, crisp, and solid on the sauce. Thank you.

Underrated slice in New York. Super crispy with 0 flop and excellent undercarriage. The slice was super juicy and flavorful.

This is a really solid slice. There really isn’t any flop and there is a nice crispness on the bottom. The cheese and sauce are really good as well with some pretty good crust too. Not bad at all.

One of the better football style pizzas pretty standard sauce and cheese but the little extra crunch on the crust gives it a few extra points a good solid pizza when you’re in the area

Absolute undercooked, raw dough garbage. Quite possibly the worst pie Ive has in NYC ever. Wanna consistently good pie? Go to Gino’s.

This score is for the round

This review is for the round

This is the prototypical Brooklyn pie. It’s large, it’s scolding hot, it’s cheesy, it’s Brooklyn. Lotta late nights at the salty dog, head over to pizza wagon for a scolding hot slice to get you through the next couple of hours. That’s what pizza wagon is about. Don’t sleep on it though. It’s not drunk pizza. It’s a solid pie. Ppl visiting take out pies from them and put them in the freezer when they go back to where they are fucking living. And by living I mean Florida. It’s a Brooklyn Institution and it should be respected.

Standard NY slice

Classic Bay Ridge spot serving average Brooklyn pizza. If you’re sober, you can find much better in BK; if you’re drunk, this pizza hits the spot. The name of the joint is legendary, the pizza ain’t.

Definitely the best slice in Bay Ridge💯

Very decent slice. If you get lucky and a Sicilian pie comes out of the oven fresh you must get a square slice or two but only if it's fresh and hot

Classic pizza. Very nice combo of everything you need / want on a pie. Crust was just a little doughy.

A solid local slice but a bit greasy but zero flop

Great Pizza, best in NY.

Fresh pie and a reheat this what what a good Sicilian pie aspires to be perfect ration of crunch, chew and fluffyness with tasty cheese and pull, sauce was good just needed a little more. Plain slice was 8.2 with grease but so much bite and flavor.

Strong Sicilian. Right up there with umbertos of new Hyde park.