If I hadn’t been 15 minutes late picking up my pizza, I would have never seen with my own eyes that none of the pies are made fresh; all of them are pre-made and reheated. This is what leads to the abundance of grease gushing from each slice. Considered to be one of the top pizza spots in Bay Ridge, I found it to be a bit overrated. When it comes to describing the cheese & sauce, the only words that come to mind are: basic, standard & generic. Not to say that’s bad, this is very much a pizza’s pizza. The sauce does have a little tang to it, sitting atop average dough with a fairly decent crisp, most likely due to the reheat factor, which also causes the crust to taste slightly stale. Open very late, clearly a good spot for drunken after hours slices, which has helped this joint’s legacy and made it an institution among Brooklyn pizza. But don’t go out of your way for a pie that’s just a notch above typical NYC dollar slice pizza.
greg.keely5/20/19, 12:16 a.m.
Damn. I thought this would be better. Had a little flavor but nothing spectacular
jason.j14/26/19, 12:26 a.m.
Very plain tasting slice. Not worth the trip. Only if you’re passing by.
ethunder2/27/19, 5:03 p.m.
Fantastic balance of taste, crunch, cheesiness. Also love the old school vibe inside
halid.lika2/14/19, 4:51 a.m.
I don’t hate it, sauce was tangy, cheese not so fresh but that’s what I get for coming in 5 minutes before they close.. 6.4, that’s a review.
philooch1/28/19, 3:53 a.m.
Its all about the square here. By far one of the best squares in brooklyn. Sauce may be a bit tangy. No flop. Lots of cheese. God bless.
sleeksilky10/27/18, 5:46 a.m.
Pretty basic pizza. Good for late night, otherwise recommend elsewhere.
jeff.obrien9/4/18, 2:04 p.m.
Very strong slice. Had both the square grandma pizza and the traditional slice. Really enjoyed their sauce. Can’t go wrong at Pizza Wagon.
eugene.ioannou8/28/18, 8:25 p.m.
Very strong slice. Got a little grease to it, but no flop. One of the most consistent and solid football pizzas in South Brooklyn. The square (sicilian) is also one of the best aside from L&B.