Pizzarelli's Pizza & Pasta

Decided to give this spot a try since it had a good score on the app, but what a mistake that was! The pizza was just a greasy, soggy mess without any real taste or other redeeming qualities. Hope this was just an off night, but very hard to recommend this place, other than for proximity to the train station if you’re running late…

Good undercarriage, slight flop, solid crust. Tangy sauce, cheese is slightly oily. Beautifully thin. Solid pizza

so good again

So yummy🥯

it was gas

Little bit of flop, but not a ton. Good crunch though. Back in scarsdale. Good sauce. Good football pizza!! Right by the train station. And the chick in there was hot! Ha.

Good flavor after reheating got a good score but it was chewy and greasy

This personal pie is what they call the Bella Pizza and it tasted better than it looked. After giving the cheese a minute to solidify, I enjoyed this whole pizza. The crust has a nice char to it! Bonus points for being one of not many pizza joints in the county to offer a personal pie as well as the option to order it with doordash to pick up yourself, a rarity for pizzerias around here!

The best out of the handful of pizza places in the village. Nothing crazy, but overall it never disappoints.

Some of the best vodka pizza I've ever had!!

Good crust. Tasty cheese. Good ratio of cheese to sauce. Little bit of Scarsdale flop, but nicely crisp. Sauce has more oregano than I like. Vodka slice is an 8.2. Plain is 6.8.