Very surprised people like this as much as the rating would suggest. Mediocre at best. Just go grab a pie at Grimaldis down the street. Even taglios over in Mineola is better
pizzamaster10109/22/23, 1:14 p.m.
Superb crunch perfect amount of sauce great undercarriage. Big fan, awesome selection. Top 5 Long Island
jason.forman9/20/23, 8:48 p.m.
Like the set up and location. This may be preference but I wound the slices to be doughy although thin, overly cheesy and sauce to be sweet and subtle. Not enough flavor there and ratios are off
chef.tom9/16/23, 2:07 a.m.
Pretty over rated and over priced they could do better especially on a Friday night.
jtrap8/12/23, 4:52 p.m.
Large variety of slices at this place. I had 3 of this batch. Generally I thought the sauce was nice and they went heavy on the cheese. Biggest issue for me was the dough. Each one had issues with the dough being not cooked enough or too stretched out to hold the cheese and sauce. My 6.9 was for the grandma which was more doughy than a traditional grandma slice but the sauce really stood out and brought up the score. Had the Portnoy which I guess is supposed to be a thin crispy slice. A bit cheese heavy and wasn’t that crispy. I went 6.7 on that one. The margherita was the disappointment of the bunch. The dough was so thinly cooked I couldn’t hold the slice. Became as floppy as a fish out of water and couldn’t finish it. That one was a 5.5
chris77/19/23, 7:46 p.m.
Both pizza and staff were amazing. Met Rob the owner who has a great personality and knew a lot about pizza. We tried both the regular slice and the Portnoy slice. Both delicious, if I had to pick one I would go with the Portnoy…Dave you mis-judged this one!!!
jay.marine7/9/23, 6:26 p.m.
Another review I forgot to put on the app that I went a while ago too. Good pizza. Little too much cheese and grease but overall good taste. This place has ALOT of specialty slices that all looked amazing.. if you’re in the area, I’d check it out for sure..
steve.hudsons11/9/22, 8:21 p.m.
I dont know whats more shocking, how bad it is or that its $5-6 slice. The high reviews were mostly one time reviews . I give it a 1.0 because its like a nyc $1 slice . Im actually insulting the $1’slice joints
tegan7299/14/22, 10:54 p.m.
Absolutely no flop, very thin and crispy without being burnt. Great sauce to cheese ratio. Really nice outdoor seating in the heart of Garden City. My highest score to date. I will definitely be back ASAP
kyle.gelling8/24/22, 5:50 p.m.
Very unique flavor, light, good mozz. Tons of specialty slices
mark.slattery7/28/22, 8:37 p.m.
Sicilian soppressta hot honey slice. Really good hot honey slice , nice char on crust. Place has a lot of specialty pies that look good, will be back to try more
jared.wasserman137/3/22, 1:24 a.m.
Best pizza I’ve had. Perfect cheese to sauce ratio and has a great crisp.
billysalts6/28/22, 4:46 p.m.
These guys make a great pizza! From the sauce to the crust, highly recommended
frank.reese11/10/21, 5:55 p.m.
Tad greasy. Tiny bit of flop. Good taste though. Looks like an 8.5, but tastes like a 7.5. Which isnt bad!