Got two gigantic slices (it was literally half a pizza) that were freshly made and a soda for $6. This is probably one of the best lunch deals I’ve ever had. The pizza is good. Sauce and cheese were both good. The crust threw me off a bit. It’s not regular pizza crust. At first I thought it had a more croissant feel to it but then it hit me, it had a buttermilk biscuit texture. Didn’t hate it, just kind of thrown off by it at first. This is just an all around good pizza with a unique crust.
Order now on Slice
Order Pizzitalia's New York Pizzeria
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
tkori10/1/22, 10:45 p.m.
I really want to rate this pizza higher. Everything about it taste delicious. The only reason I rated it where I did is that the dough is very heavy and the cheese falls off the slice when you try to pull it. I ate three slices and was completely full even though I was starving when I arrived. That dough, while tasting good, is the heaviest dough I have ever eaten.
rit10109/18/21, 10:41 p.m.
Decided to venture out of town to discover a new pizza place and here is where we ended up! We had a large cheese pizza with extra cheese and an order of garlic knots and both were excellent! Loved the vibe of this place as well! A great spot to bring friends and family. Pizza had a nice thin flavored crust and excellent sauce. I personally liked the cheese but it’s definitely going to be the difference maker on how much you’ll enjoy this pizza. It’s got a pretty strong flavor that definitely stands out. Anyway, great place! Totally happy with this discovery!
andrew.ross95/3/21, 10:35 p.m.
Had to put a swimsuit on for the grease but overall good tasting. Tampa flop but decent undercarriage. Cheese was the best part. Wife wasn’t as fond. She gave a 5
dylan.causey4/2/21, 10:07 p.m.
Solid pizza. Had a classic flop. Not greasy which is a plus. The sauce blended with the cheese wonderfully. Crust was light but pure. 7.9 score.
tommyyg2/16/21, 12:30 a.m.
Not a bad pie here Frankie...nice all around flavor with a nice light crust.
sdm.sdm9/7/20, 12:11 a.m.
One of the best New York style pizzas I’ve had in Tampa (better than Eddie and Sam’s in downtown Tampa if you’re looking for a local gauge. The balance of flavor in their red sauce is on point for all the dishes they use it in. The owner really cares about all the products he puts out from the line. Best thing when trying their pizza is to eat it blazing hot.
david.defiore7/24/19, 4:49 p.m.
Some flop, but the bottom has a nice crispiness to it. Crust is a little dry. Sauce is great too
linnet.kiser7/15/19, 1:29 a.m.
Delicious pizza. Crust has the perfect amount of garlic flavor and a great texture and crisp. Cheese and tomatoes were very fresh and flavorful.