Plank's Cafe & Pizzeria

I’m shocked that the average is only a 7.8. This pizza is unique and tastes fantastic. If you don’t like sweet crust, this isn’t the pie for you, and you’re bland.

Sauce on the pepperoni was too sweet. Overpowers all of the other flavors. The Cajun Chicken pie however was much better, but also very sweet.

This is the best pizzeria in Columbus, maybe in Ohio. Incredible pizza and a great family small business. If you like pizza and think you know good pizza, you’ll enjoy Plank’s.

This pizza isn’t bad but it’s not all that great. The crust kinda of has an odd sweet flavor that I don’t care much for.

One of my all time favorites. Great family!

By far my favorite pizza, there’s a great sweet and spicy from the pepperoni and the crust… hands down the best around.

Different style than what I normally like, but crust pairs well with the pizza.

Good

Open for business since 1939 - doesn’t matter, we score it firm but firm. Party style.. tossup with Grandad’s. This is AFC North stuff. Dawg Pound during Romeo Crennel stuff. We’re hungry though so it hit. 6.8.

Favorite pizza I’ve had so far in Columbus. Texture of pizza is wonderful, crisp pepperonis. Pizza heaven. Is a little sweet but I loved it

Not my typical style of pizza. It’s a sweet sour dough crust with an equally sweet sauce. That being said it is built in the Columbus style that is so dear to my heart. Thin crust, square cut and that pepperoni that curls perfectly. Best city for pizza on earth bar none. Only thing I would improve on this is to cook the cheese more. Definitely worth a try if in German Village.

Went with the Pizza King of Columbus, it’s good, sweet sauce is it unique

Decent pie reminds me of when my grandfather used to bring me here.

Really good pizza tavern. The sauce is sweet, the crust is your traditional columbus meets donatos style cut. Highly recommend for nostalgia and atmosphere.

Columbus staple, and one of the places that I recommend to people who haven't been in town. Classic atmosphere with great service and people.

Good not great. Honestly thought it was going to be a lot better. Tasted like they put a pound of sugar in the sauce, also very doughy.

Very good taste, however, a little undercooked and doughy. I knocked off a few points for this. The friend I'm said it's not usually like this. Again, a good pizza.