Pontillo's Pizzeria

The best pie in Monroe county and it’s not debatable. Perfect amount of sauce to cheese ratio. The toppings are always fresh and plentiful. Only reason this pie didn’t get a 9 is it could have been left in the oven a minute or two longer. This specific pontillios is the best pizza in Monroe county, possibly WNY

You're not a pizza fan in Rochester if you haven't had Pontillo's in the Basin. Great takeout pie, lovely flavor and perfect amount of sauce. Little heavy on the cheese but cooked well so you won't find me complaining. Really solid and certainly one of the best spots in the area.

Just got a slice of pepperoni.. feel like it could’ve been higher but I went at 3 in the afternoon and this one might have been sitting around for a while. Probably a mid 8 if I got a whole pizza fresh.

Didn’t know I needed a picture to score and showed it down too quick. Solid pizza

This is a confusing pie. The very middle was delicious, a good mix of sauce, dough, and cheese. The closer to the crust the flavor disappeared. They use a little corn meal on the bottom which I like, and the sauce has a nice tang. If they used a little less dough this could be pushing an 8

Excellent pizza

It’s better than I remember. Solid slice for sure.

Best Pontillos location! Always an awesome slice!

Doughy, bland sauce but edible..goof crisp crust

Literally best lunch spot in the area. The sauce is a good thang and the cheese is perfect and not too greasy. The crunch is on point. Highly recommended.

Perfect chewy, great suace

The best in all of Rochester but...never a perfect 10. Good flop, good tang, all around great pizza

Bomb

Solid slice

All around great slice

Alright Frankie 8.6 that’s a good score

Good pizza none of this 9.8 crap