Poseidon’s Italian Kitchen

Fresh outta the oven! Bit of grease, bit of flop but great overall. Also, can’t beat the location right on the boulevard (ocean) and the service was great too. 7.9, Gloucester pizza joints just don’t disappoint!

100% best in the area! Shockingly surprised as a New Yorker by the quality of this pie. Superb thin football style. Great people.

A little greasy and lots of flop, but the flavor is incredible

Alright Frankie this pie brought me back to one I had when I was a kid growing up just outside of Atlanta — it reminded me of a joint called Star Pizza. It was okay Frankie.... I wouldn’t drive out of my way to come here but it was a good “sit on a park bench and watch the seagulls fly” type of pie. Very basic. Cheese was and sauce were good but had a weird way of complimenting each other. Had a funny taste in my mouth Frankie while eating the pie. Not sure you want that if you want a solid score on your joint... just sayin’ Frankie. 5.5.... that’s a review.

Hayes coming in hot to Poseidon’s and jamming hard to the pandora playlist. He’s a bit of a rookie and sometimes he mixes up decimal points and fractions. Don’t judge

A little biased but this my go to