This is the thin crust. Not cracker thin but more like hand tossed. The sauce is simple and yummy, the cheese is sharp, and the pepperoni is salty, almost too salty. Even for me. I requested a well done cook but there is zero crisp. It’s very doughy like the deep dish I reviewed.my gripes are the crust and the heavy saltiness. These guys have a great history through covid, check out their backstory. The staff is very friendly and appear to be pizza connoisseurs themselves. For pizza this style I’m giving it a lesser score than the deep dish because I think this could’ve had a little more potential. Check out my deep dish review.
kelly.niece2/8/21, 1:18 a.m.
Great pizza. Chicago style. Deep dish. Outside crust was a little tough to bite into which was the only reason it wasn’t a 9. 100% would go out of my way to go get this pizza.
matt.ketron3/31/20, 10:22 p.m.
Get off the couch and hit up Poseidon’s. Top pizza in the Greater Cincinnati area!
reeseharr2/22/20, 5:39 a.m.
Fantastic taste in the sauce and toppings!! The dough is cooked just right very good service will be getting more soon
madison.gilbert12/21/20, 6:53 p.m.
This is the best pizza I’ve ever had!! Let me tell you...AMAZING staff and delicious pizza. Everything always tastes so fresh !
eli.rossi2/21/20, 6:12 p.m.
I could eat this pizza everyday, the cheese and the sauce have been perfected. Great service!
charles.brown22/21/20, 6:04 p.m.
The pizza was amazing and the staff was awesome definitely will recommend Poseidon’s to all my friends and family!
savannah.allen2/21/20, 5:46 p.m.
Got the lil deep dish from Poseidon’s... best pizza I have ever had. Crust was perfect, just the right amount of cheese & toppings. Sauce is delicious! Keep up the great work
timothy.perry2/1/20, 5:41 p.m.
Large Cheese Pie - $15.99 Here it is... review number 98. (Please follow me if you like my reviews) Only been open for 7 months. Loved the smell. I was super pumped at first. But.... unfortunately didn’t deliver with taste. The crust is doughy. Little flavor. Love the sauce and cheese. They put a little garlic and Parmesan along the outside. They use a convey belt oven. Disappointing. Brick oven would electrify this pizza. Over all... it’s not bad but not great.
chad.moore312/16/19, 12:06 a.m.
This place is legit. Football pizza with great flavor, including the crust, and it is consistently well made. The service is excellent as well.